During the pre-trial process in the Theranos fraud case last year, presiding District Judge Edward Davila issued a ruling that surprised virtually everyone following the case: co-defendants Elizabeth Holmes, the founder and CEO of the failed blood-testing company, and Ramesh ‘Sunny’ Balwani, her former partner and from 2009 Theranos’ COO, would be tried separately and not together as originally expected.
In early September, unredacted portions of her legal team’s filings revealed why. Holmes’ defence will partly depend on demonstrating that she was subjected to “a pattern of abuse and coercive behaviour” during the relationship whereby Balwani was a toxic influence who drove her into a resulting pattern of deception towards potential shareholders and members of staff. The abuse included, it will be alleged, verbal bullying, puppet-like control of Holmes’ behaviour and public image, and instances of attempted physical violence.
It needs to be said that...