How do we solve the Catch 22 of Skills?

Employers are frustrated that young people emerging from education don’t have the skills they are looking for. Young people emerging from education are keen to work but can’t get jobs because they don’t have the skills employers are looking for. A classic Catch 22 conundrum – how do we fix this?

Last month the IET published a skills survey that was launched at a joint event with Student Energy, who were presenting a report of their own on young people entering the energy transition labour market. The lively debate that took place is available to view. The organisations spoke respectively to employers and students both groups expressing a clear desire for more and better training to help bridge the gap between formal education and employment, and for career progression into new roles or to cover new responsibilities.  

Apprenticeships, graduate programmes, and internships are a great way to receive practical training, but these programmes are only available to a minority, and often those working for larger organisation.

How do we find different ways to bridge this gap? Could accessible online learning be an acceptable alternative that employers would consider? Perhaps young engineers already have the skills, but they are not presenting them in the right way because they don’t know how?

If engineers can’t find a solution to this, I don’t know who can – what are your thoughts?

Parents
  • Many many years ago I was offered an apprenticeship with an aircraft manufacturer, no space industry then. If I had accepted I would have been expected to go on day release for qualifications up to HND level and be expected to work for the company for a long time if not my working life. 

    Recently the son of a friend, my offspring are all female and have no interest in engineering despite my best efforts, was offered an apprenticeship with the now aerospace company.  He asked what qualifications he would be expected to study for and get. He was told "none" they would teach him everything that was needed to do the job! He declined and accepted an apprenticeship with a water company where he was expected to get qualifications. 

    Having completed his apprenticeship and got qualifications he  left the water company, partly due to the dangerous incompetence of his managers, and gained a well paid job with a smaller company that does not do apprenticeships!

    I suspect that  part of the problem is if good apprenticeships are offered they cost companies a lot of money and the qualified apprentices  then leave for better paid jobs. The poor low cost apprenticeships do not appeal to those who have the potential skills to do much better.

    I saw an apprenticeship for a barista being offered. A temporary job one of my daughters mastered the basics of  after a few hours training. 

    In addition the low respect in the country for engineers and expectation of low pay when compared to lawyers, accountants etc means that any engineering type job does not attract the volume of suitable applicants. Along with the expectation that engineers get their hands dirty. Not helped by the throwaway society where fixing things is not done. Usually because it is almost impossible as many items are designed as non maintainable and even if you know what is wrong the spares are not available, assuming you do not have to destroy the item to fit the spare. So youngsters do not get the opportunity to practice breaking and fixing things or learn the effects of CRT High Tension voltage on the human body :) 

    I have a little GoPro camera and have learnt that to replace the failing rechargeable  battery I would need to destroy the camera! I have seen a video of how to disassemble one without actually completely destroying it but it did not cover how to reassemble the disassembled bits:(

    Unfortunately I can not suggest any practical cost effective solutions.

Reply
  • Many many years ago I was offered an apprenticeship with an aircraft manufacturer, no space industry then. If I had accepted I would have been expected to go on day release for qualifications up to HND level and be expected to work for the company for a long time if not my working life. 

    Recently the son of a friend, my offspring are all female and have no interest in engineering despite my best efforts, was offered an apprenticeship with the now aerospace company.  He asked what qualifications he would be expected to study for and get. He was told "none" they would teach him everything that was needed to do the job! He declined and accepted an apprenticeship with a water company where he was expected to get qualifications. 

    Having completed his apprenticeship and got qualifications he  left the water company, partly due to the dangerous incompetence of his managers, and gained a well paid job with a smaller company that does not do apprenticeships!

    I suspect that  part of the problem is if good apprenticeships are offered they cost companies a lot of money and the qualified apprentices  then leave for better paid jobs. The poor low cost apprenticeships do not appeal to those who have the potential skills to do much better.

    I saw an apprenticeship for a barista being offered. A temporary job one of my daughters mastered the basics of  after a few hours training. 

    In addition the low respect in the country for engineers and expectation of low pay when compared to lawyers, accountants etc means that any engineering type job does not attract the volume of suitable applicants. Along with the expectation that engineers get their hands dirty. Not helped by the throwaway society where fixing things is not done. Usually because it is almost impossible as many items are designed as non maintainable and even if you know what is wrong the spares are not available, assuming you do not have to destroy the item to fit the spare. So youngsters do not get the opportunity to practice breaking and fixing things or learn the effects of CRT High Tension voltage on the human body :) 

    I have a little GoPro camera and have learnt that to replace the failing rechargeable  battery I would need to destroy the camera! I have seen a video of how to disassemble one without actually completely destroying it but it did not cover how to reassemble the disassembled bits:(

    Unfortunately I can not suggest any practical cost effective solutions.

Children
No Data