This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

What is Fellowship?

I'm not sure which forum this belongs in, this seems to be the closest?


A question, what is Fellowship in the context of the IET? Is it the recognition by the profession of somebody who stands out in their field, their profession and in general as an engineer and character? Or is it just a "supersize" membership.

As the only route to Fellowship of the IET seems to be by applying on your own behalf, it looks like the latter. There doesn't seem to be any scope for recognising those engineers who really do stand out, but aren't self-seeking enough to look for recognition. I know personally some engineers who in my opinion are natural Fellows but would never put themselves forward for this recognition.
Parents
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member
    From time to time, I notice - in members news or somewhere on the IET website - a member who has achieved degree(s), CEng, FIET, and even MBE;  and yet their picture suggests they're in their 20s; and appear to have achieved all this from just one job role, or have worked only for one company.


    One cannot help but think whether the member(s), as young as they appear to be, are genius engineers; good at form filling, or some other special factor - that doesn't apply to the rest of us - one could only compare it to an overseas athlete, who's been "fast tracked" to a British Passport, so they could compete for Team GB at the Olympic games.


    Perhaps, the last enquirer might qualify for this "Fast Track" route. But then again, what do I know?


    What I do know is that before the mergers, where we had the IEE, IERE, IProdE (forgot their changed name), IEEIE, SERT, IMechIE, and others I forget. It was much easier to achieve fellowship from the smaller institutions/Societies.


    The so called multinational IET has completely barred the vast majority of members from achieving fellowship, due to the entry level being too high. Those wishing to gain fellowship would be better off achieving an honour from the Queen and tea at Buckingham Pl.
Reply
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member
    From time to time, I notice - in members news or somewhere on the IET website - a member who has achieved degree(s), CEng, FIET, and even MBE;  and yet their picture suggests they're in their 20s; and appear to have achieved all this from just one job role, or have worked only for one company.


    One cannot help but think whether the member(s), as young as they appear to be, are genius engineers; good at form filling, or some other special factor - that doesn't apply to the rest of us - one could only compare it to an overseas athlete, who's been "fast tracked" to a British Passport, so they could compete for Team GB at the Olympic games.


    Perhaps, the last enquirer might qualify for this "Fast Track" route. But then again, what do I know?


    What I do know is that before the mergers, where we had the IEE, IERE, IProdE (forgot their changed name), IEEIE, SERT, IMechIE, and others I forget. It was much easier to achieve fellowship from the smaller institutions/Societies.


    The so called multinational IET has completely barred the vast majority of members from achieving fellowship, due to the entry level being too high. Those wishing to gain fellowship would be better off achieving an honour from the Queen and tea at Buckingham Pl.
Children
No Data