This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Electrical Installation



Although the picture below reflects the poor workmanship of cable tray installation, but I would like to know experts comments, if this method of cable tray cutting & installation  is acceptable as per NEMA & other industry standards ?

7b92ef7fc2193d6442ae4a0d602d984b-huge-tray-installation.jpg
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member
    NEC or CEC codes (depending where you are) might apply, rather than NEMA which I think is a manufacturers standard. It certainly looks horrible and I dont think those strips of rubber will last the lifetime of the rest of the installation.



  • Dear Ian,


    You are right. NEMA VE-1 & VE-2 are manufacture standards, NEC section 392.5(B) & NEMA VE-2 section 3.6.2, clearly state


    1) The cable trays shall not have sharp edges, burrs or projections that could damage the insulation or jacket of wiring.


    2) After Cutting cable tray edges shall be smooth to remove burrs.


    Generally branch cable trays are cut at site & connected using 90 degree conncetors or TEE fittings, But this is for the first time, I came across this kind of  innovative installation, though the picture below reflects poor workmanship but  fortunately cables were laid without damage & there is space around the cut out to add more cables without damaging. I also thought it is the rubber that surrounds the cut out, but contractor have turned up the peice of tray peice that was cut, so there will not be sharp edges but only curve & smooth edges.

    a21ccff84acfcfad747e7be2ab470058-huge-branch-cable-tray.jpg


    So I am still in doubt, as it is not voilating the standard but at the same time it is not a general & good practice to make small cut out in side rail of cable trays.
  • It was very poor design in the laying of cables in this case. Someone must have overlooked and was forced to do it in the manner that is unconventional.


    Regards

    Chris Chew
  • I Agree with all Experts Opinion. Contractor was informed to do necessary modifications immediately for his  " Innovation " .

    Thank you all !!