The IET is carrying out some important updates between 17-30 April and all of our websites will be view only. For more information, read this Announcement

This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

C&G Professional Recognition Awards

Former Community Member
Former Community Member
Afternoon all,

I've come across, and not found much infomation on the net regarding C&Gs PRAs like LCGI, AfCGI, GCGI and MCGI.


Maybe someone could clear this up for me, but my interpritation of what these are or are supposed to be, is something for people with experience in engineering but without the formal achademic qualifications - awarding a particular award based upon experience which some how corresponds to the type of qualification someone in their job would typically have? So for example, having a GCGI is like having a bachelors degree?


Are such qualifications actually worth having? Are they recognised by industry, or is it more a "buy a title" type situation?


If someone could explain what exactly these really are (and not just marketed as), and what their really worth etc. Sadly C&Gs give very limited info on their site (as per usual).


Lee.
Parents
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member

    Larkland Morley:

    In Canada, you cannot use the term Engineer officially




    It's a great country, but I wonder what engineering and technology products - commercial or domestic - do Canada export to the UK, or the world for that matter? What do we have in the UK that says 'made in Canada'?


    There could be some small island, somewhere in the world, that may have set the highest standards ever to practice as an engineer; even higher than Canada and UK put together. But their export market is Bananas.


    One possible reason for setting such high standards might be in the event an engineer makes an error - health and safety - which could result in the entire population being wiped out, as they're only say 300 people living there. But should the population of engineers in the UK need to concern themselves with the merits of registration, because one of us might be thinking of immigrating to that remote island?


    I sense there is an unbalanced obsession from some members with respect to UK registration, when comparing with standards set by other countries.


    I have no doubt in my mind that if the EC ever required registrants to demonstrate proof of having run the London marathon (as a 3 legged race) and climbed Mount Everest - at least to base camp - there will be some people who would strive to achieve it, just for the title of CEng or IEng; because they're simply geeky or nerdy and obsessive enough to do it. yessmiley


    From my perspective, if I were ever to immigrate to Canada and wished to practice as an engineer, I would simply take whatever exams that were required of me. Simple as that!

Reply
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member

    Larkland Morley:

    In Canada, you cannot use the term Engineer officially




    It's a great country, but I wonder what engineering and technology products - commercial or domestic - do Canada export to the UK, or the world for that matter? What do we have in the UK that says 'made in Canada'?


    There could be some small island, somewhere in the world, that may have set the highest standards ever to practice as an engineer; even higher than Canada and UK put together. But their export market is Bananas.


    One possible reason for setting such high standards might be in the event an engineer makes an error - health and safety - which could result in the entire population being wiped out, as they're only say 300 people living there. But should the population of engineers in the UK need to concern themselves with the merits of registration, because one of us might be thinking of immigrating to that remote island?


    I sense there is an unbalanced obsession from some members with respect to UK registration, when comparing with standards set by other countries.


    I have no doubt in my mind that if the EC ever required registrants to demonstrate proof of having run the London marathon (as a 3 legged race) and climbed Mount Everest - at least to base camp - there will be some people who would strive to achieve it, just for the title of CEng or IEng; because they're simply geeky or nerdy and obsessive enough to do it. yessmiley


    From my perspective, if I were ever to immigrate to Canada and wished to practice as an engineer, I would simply take whatever exams that were required of me. Simple as that!

Children
No Data