This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Is technology killing the NHS?

I'm sorry if this comes across as pessimistic but I believe that the NHS will die unless seriously intelligent reforms are made to it. These reforms will probably not be possible because of inertia in the system. What happened to Stafford Hospital is a snapshot of what will come to other NHS trusts.


When the NHS was established in the 1940s, technology in hospitals was far simpler. In many cases medical procedures were carried out using simple hand tools. The most complicated piece of equipment in a hospital was probably an X-Ray machine. A modern hospital contains tens of thousands of pieces of advanced machinery.


This costs a large amount of money to buy.

This costs a large amount of money to maintain and service.

This costs a large amount of money to provide staff training.


The amount of money spent by hospitals on advanced medical devices and IT equipment keeps increasing year after year and is a substantial part of the NHS budget.


If this isn't bad enough in itself, the NHS is not very good when it comes to using and deploying technology due to its cumbersome and antiquated management structure along with the mentality of a high proportion of its staff. The NHS is clearly not a visionary and progressive organisation.


Only a small fraction of medical devices are specifically designed for the NHS. A high proportion of them are off the shelf products primarily designed for the US healthcare market.


The situation is marginally better with software although NHS IT projects are known to have been expensive disasters.


Therefore, is technology killing the NHS?
Parents

  • Arran Cameron:


    Whenever I have mentioned the concept of vertical integration in order to reduce costs (ultimately to the taxpayer) and ensure that medical devices meed the requirements of the NHS and its patients I have been accused of socialism.

    You socialist you. Hospitals will be needed for a long time yet for A & E.

    Also, why should nursing staff be put back into control? Why not have engineers in control instead?

    Because Nursing staff know the business.

    There is a problem whether it would be legal to sell certain medical devices to the public for home / self treatment.

    It is already happening and has been for over 80 years in the US the equipment is being sold as frequency generators.

    I'm in favour of genetic modification of humans as this will add a completely new dimension into medicine.

    I am not at this time. The arrogant stupidity of man never ceases to amaze me in that they thought things would be simple and there would be a gene identified for each aspect of humans but it turns out a tomato has three times the genes. Surely it makes more sense to use Electrotherapy to cure us of diseases first that are our main problem and then try and improve the body. An improved body is not much good if it can be taken out by a simple virus. It is much easier to wipe out the virus or other pathogens than redesign the human genome to fight them off. There is the added problem that just like antibiotic resistance the super body would need to adapt to new pathogens but Electrotherapy can always give a solution to wipe them out and not leave any to become resistant.

     

Reply

  • Arran Cameron:


    Whenever I have mentioned the concept of vertical integration in order to reduce costs (ultimately to the taxpayer) and ensure that medical devices meed the requirements of the NHS and its patients I have been accused of socialism.

    You socialist you. Hospitals will be needed for a long time yet for A & E.

    Also, why should nursing staff be put back into control? Why not have engineers in control instead?

    Because Nursing staff know the business.

    There is a problem whether it would be legal to sell certain medical devices to the public for home / self treatment.

    It is already happening and has been for over 80 years in the US the equipment is being sold as frequency generators.

    I'm in favour of genetic modification of humans as this will add a completely new dimension into medicine.

    I am not at this time. The arrogant stupidity of man never ceases to amaze me in that they thought things would be simple and there would be a gene identified for each aspect of humans but it turns out a tomato has three times the genes. Surely it makes more sense to use Electrotherapy to cure us of diseases first that are our main problem and then try and improve the body. An improved body is not much good if it can be taken out by a simple virus. It is much easier to wipe out the virus or other pathogens than redesign the human genome to fight them off. There is the added problem that just like antibiotic resistance the super body would need to adapt to new pathogens but Electrotherapy can always give a solution to wipe them out and not leave any to become resistant.

     

Children
No Data