This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Oil for plain bearings

Former Community Member
Former Community Member
Hello all. I am looking for some advice on oil for sintered bronze bearings in an old motor(1/2hp). The manufacturer's plate says to add 15 drops of non-detergent SAE 20 oil every year. On a plain bearing with no force-feed lubrication, is detergent(motor) oil going to harm the bearings/journal? The only comment I have found online other than do/do not use, is that the detergents may dissolve the insulation on the windings. Another comment was that if put in a gear box, detergent oil will foam. I had a friend who used GTX20W50 in his car gearbox without any issues. I have a bench grinder with a worm drive for a wet wheel. I put a clear cover on the drive and put gearbox oil in. It foams away merrily!!

I understand most forums are run by self -styled experts( e.g. bobistheoilguy)who have little to no actual knowledge.
Parents
  • There is a controversy whether vintage machinery is best lubricated with vintage lubricants, that were around at the time it was manufactured, or whether modern formulations are better.


    I have some synchronous electric clocks and the manufacturers recommended using engine oil to lubricate the bearings with (the gears run dry) but this happened to be the single grade engine oils sold in the 1930s to the 1950s. Modern synthetic multigrade engine oils are unsuitable as they contain all sorts of detergents and additives that can damage the mechanisms and stain brass.
Reply
  • There is a controversy whether vintage machinery is best lubricated with vintage lubricants, that were around at the time it was manufactured, or whether modern formulations are better.


    I have some synchronous electric clocks and the manufacturers recommended using engine oil to lubricate the bearings with (the gears run dry) but this happened to be the single grade engine oils sold in the 1930s to the 1950s. Modern synthetic multigrade engine oils are unsuitable as they contain all sorts of detergents and additives that can damage the mechanisms and stain brass.
Children
No Data