Currently in a dispute with a customer over bootlace ferrules I have used in screw-clamp type terminals - this is an industrial control panel designed to BS EN 60204-1, the wire used is class 5 tri-rated.
The customer says bootlace ferrules are the wrong type and wants them changing to fork-type crimps, arguing that the screw-clamp applies even pressure on fork crimps and a better contact but not so when ferrules are used - if you can picture the bootlace-ferrule on one side of the screw- with its clamp being at an angle as there is nothing on the other side of the screw. However, the termination is tight and makes a good solid contact with the ferrule so I think this is perfectly acceptable.
While I wouldn't generally disagree with a customer, there are hundreds of terminals to change, they didn't specify fork-crimps at design stages and I don't interpret anywhere in BS 60204-1 or BS 60947-1 that ferrules are wrong in screw-clamps.
Any opinions much appreciated.
The IET is carrying out some important updates between 17-30 April and all of our websites will be view only. For more information, read this Announcement
