This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Room 101 - Steam, Diesel or Electric trains?

If you had to put either steam, diesel or electric trains into ‘room 101’, which would it be and why?  ? 

???

Parents
  • Russell Bulley: 
     

    John Jacobs: 
     

    The nostalgia for steam trains is all very well and is still an earner of tourist revenue. As an engineer I have to remember that a steam loco is only about 27% efficient. Sorry, but it goes into room 101.

    And a car is 28-30%!

    Well, that's just the thermal efficiency of the engine running off its tank/bunker. Is there a study of the overall journey efficiency, taking into account construction costs, etc. Even that doesn't account for pollution, accidents, etc.

Reply
  • Russell Bulley: 
     

    John Jacobs: 
     

    The nostalgia for steam trains is all very well and is still an earner of tourist revenue. As an engineer I have to remember that a steam loco is only about 27% efficient. Sorry, but it goes into room 101.

    And a car is 28-30%!

    Well, that's just the thermal efficiency of the engine running off its tank/bunker. Is there a study of the overall journey efficiency, taking into account construction costs, etc. Even that doesn't account for pollution, accidents, etc.

Children
No Data