This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

How Many Wind Turbines

An interesting piece in E&T.

https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2021/10/spare-wind-energy-could-be-converted-to-hydrogen-to-power-uk-in-winter/

This comes up with a requirement for seasonal timescale storage of energy using hydrogen to reduce the installed wind power capacity in 2050 from 600 GW down to a mere 190 GW.

The full paper is downloadable here:

www.energynetworks.org/.../renewable-hydrogen-offers-best-route-out-of-future-energy-supply-crunches

So 600 GW is one hundred thousand  6MW wind turbines. Assuming that these would need to be separated by 1 km to avoid blocking each other’s wind (is that a sensible guess?) this would require an area of around 300 km x 300 km. Where shall we put them? The proposed 190 GW will require an area of around 170 km x 170 km, still not easy to install, if offshore they would have to be in deep water or floating.

What are the resources required to build them? Figures are hard to find but I have a report from the United States Geological Survey which is a little old but gives weights of various materials per MW. Newer optimised designs may use less, offshore probably uses more.

https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2011/5036/sir2011-5036.pdf

Table 5, page 12,  gives 100 tonnes of steel per MW and 400 tonnes of concrete per MW. 

190 GW installed capacity will require 19 million tonnes of steel and 76 million tonnes of concrete. 

Not impossible amounts when spread over a couple of decades, but a lot of energy to pay back.

 

Parents
  • Accepted practice for spacing is 6-10 rotor diameters.  the diameter for a 6MW unit will be ~ 150m, so 1km is certainly not wild of the mark, and could be more. 

    The North sea is typically 50-100m deep so support will be an odd mix of sea floor and floating

Reply
  • Accepted practice for spacing is 6-10 rotor diameters.  the diameter for a 6MW unit will be ~ 150m, so 1km is certainly not wild of the mark, and could be more. 

    The North sea is typically 50-100m deep so support will be an odd mix of sea floor and floating

Children
No Data