This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Menstrual Leave: Extra 3 days paid leave a month for Italian women may become law

Has anyone else seen this...?


Italy might soon become the first Western country with an official “menstrual leave” policy for working women. The lower house of Italy’s parliament has started discussing a draft law that, if approved, will mandate companies to grant three days of paid leave each month to female employees who experience painful periods. “It has been shown that women who suffer severe pain during their period are much less productive in these days,” said Simonetta Rubinato, a politician who put the law forward with three other female lawmakers. “Recognising their right to be absent from work during that time means they will be much more productive when they return.


Some fear that the law might backfire, penalising women in a country where they are already struggling to participate in the workforce. If women were granted extra days of paid leave, wrote Lorenza Pleuteri in Donna Moderna, a women’s magazine, “employers could become even more oriented to hire men rather than women”.


Italy has one of the lowest rates of female participation in the workforce in Europe. Only 61 percent of Italian women work, well below the European average of 72 per cent. This is due in part to employers’ reluctance to hire women and retain them after they become mothers. According to a report by ISTAT, Italy's national bureau of statistics, almost one-fourth of pregnant workers are fired during or right after their pregnancies – even though doing so is illegal.


Menstrual leave has been a legal right for Japanese women since 1947, but fear of social stigma means many will not take it. “If you take menstrual leave, you’re basically broadcasting to the entire office which days of the month you have your period,” said Kyoko, a professional woman in her 30s, who asked for her real name to be withheld. “It’s not the sort of thing you want to share with male colleagues, and it could lead to sexual harassment.


Some UK companies are also starting to offer this policy. Read more: 





Would be interested to hear thoughts on this. Is this a step towards equality and greater flexible working policies or a step backwards by marking women as incapable 3 days a month? Would you be comfortable with your colleagues (and possibly your clients) knowing your personal bodily functions? Would extra time off cause resentment from male colleagues/managers? Or from female colleagues/managers who choose not to take it? Would the potential for women to take extra days off mean employers would be less likely to hire/promote women in the first place?
Parents

  • Antonia Tzemanaki:




    Lisa Miles:

    Personally I think this is a crazy idea in a world where women have a hard enough time being taken seriously in the workplace (and generally too). The 'entitlement' to take an extra 3 days leave  per month will only result in more resentment, not only from men who are unable to benefit from such a law but other colleagues who continually have to take up the slack.


    I've never had to take time off for this reason. A couple of painkillers usually does the trick... 


     




    I personally think that 3 days is a lot. However, we must be careful not to judge everyone by our personal habits and situation. There are women who are in extreme pain and no matter the numer of painkillers, the pain will not go away. I have personally woken up vomitting from the pain, and then had to go to work after some painkillers. I would not have minded to have that specific day off - and I am sure other women have worse problems than me. At the same time, if you do not need the day off you don't have to take it, but it would be good to have it as an option for those who need it.


     


     




    I agree with you Antonia, that taking a day off when the pain is too much is an option, I just see it as a optional part of the usual annual leave - I speak from the luxury of having a decent number of days of annual leave, when fully employed. Like you, the pain did keep me awake (despite the painkiller tablets), vomitting and shivering - I had to give up a part-time MSc course at Keele because the dreaded pain concided every month with the three days I had to be at Keele.

Reply

  • Antonia Tzemanaki:




    Lisa Miles:

    Personally I think this is a crazy idea in a world where women have a hard enough time being taken seriously in the workplace (and generally too). The 'entitlement' to take an extra 3 days leave  per month will only result in more resentment, not only from men who are unable to benefit from such a law but other colleagues who continually have to take up the slack.


    I've never had to take time off for this reason. A couple of painkillers usually does the trick... 


     




    I personally think that 3 days is a lot. However, we must be careful not to judge everyone by our personal habits and situation. There are women who are in extreme pain and no matter the numer of painkillers, the pain will not go away. I have personally woken up vomitting from the pain, and then had to go to work after some painkillers. I would not have minded to have that specific day off - and I am sure other women have worse problems than me. At the same time, if you do not need the day off you don't have to take it, but it would be good to have it as an option for those who need it.


     


     




    I agree with you Antonia, that taking a day off when the pain is too much is an option, I just see it as a optional part of the usual annual leave - I speak from the luxury of having a decent number of days of annual leave, when fully employed. Like you, the pain did keep me awake (despite the painkiller tablets), vomitting and shivering - I had to give up a part-time MSc course at Keele because the dreaded pain concided every month with the three days I had to be at Keele.

Children
No Data