This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Type-A RCD failing 180 degree ramp test

Former Community Member
Former Community Member
Hi


We are testing a type-A RCD (see image: "ABB") with a METREL MI 3152 (see image: "MI 3152 test").

As the image shows, the ramp test (I delta) is failing to trip the RCD for the negative half wave.


Have oneone seen this before?


Br Sebastian
attachments.zip
Parents
  • A 1A RCD is pretty deaf, but quite sensible for something big and 3 phase.

    I presume the load is not something known to inject DC into the L-E loop as part of normal operation ?

    How many RCDs of this type have you tested with this meter ? Normally I'd say 'try a known good one' but that may not be so easy, as it would be for 30mA  say.

    So, while a 5A test is out, can your meter extend to a test at higher current say 2A?, and also does it matter which combination of phase and earth are selected for the test ? I'm wondering if swapping the phases would reveal that really one phase is slightly less sensitive.  For that matter are the supply voltages for all 3 phases present and correct ?

Reply
  • A 1A RCD is pretty deaf, but quite sensible for something big and 3 phase.

    I presume the load is not something known to inject DC into the L-E loop as part of normal operation ?

    How many RCDs of this type have you tested with this meter ? Normally I'd say 'try a known good one' but that may not be so easy, as it would be for 30mA  say.

    So, while a 5A test is out, can your meter extend to a test at higher current say 2A?, and also does it matter which combination of phase and earth are selected for the test ? I'm wondering if swapping the phases would reveal that really one phase is slightly less sensitive.  For that matter are the supply voltages for all 3 phases present and correct ?

Children
No Data