Rules and Guidelines
Want to participate in the discussions? Please read our Community Rules and Guidelines. Need some help? Visit Support and Answers.

  • State Not Answered
  • Locked Locked
  • Replies 12 replies
  • Subscribers 32 subscribers
  • Views 9405 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Options
You may also be interested in
This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Low current Zs test tripping RCBO

Sparkymania
Hi


Have a question about RCD testing. I'm not new to testing and have been doing it for quite a few years now but have come across something that has never happened before.


On Zs testing a circuits on a DB with all RCBOs every one of them trip on a 2 wire low test. I didn't find this out until I did the lighting as the sockets use 3 wire and I allow the default selection of 3 wire low. Using Megger MFT. All 3 lighting circuits did this. I used a 3 wire low (using 3 probes) and they didn't trip. I tried the socket circuits on 2 wire low and they did trip.

All load turned off.


I'm guessing the use of the neutral in the test allows some balancing current through the RCBO but then I don't know the technical differences between 2 and 3 wire low test and can't find any details on it anywhere. I suspect, even if I could find it it may go into so much detail it would go over my head.


The question is why are they tripping? No Load. IR tests all >999. 


Anyone got any Ideas?


Parents
  • 0
    I think most (usually A-type) RCBOs these days are much more sensitive to residual currents that aren't nice pure sine waves than the traditional AC type RCCBs. That makes life much harder for loop testers - it's difficult to get an accurately measurable change in voltage from a maximum 15mA leakage current - so they usually resort to all sorts of tricks to use larger currents for very short durations to try to work out the loop impedance. In 3-wire mode where the meter has access to the L-N voltage and L-N loop it can deduce a certain amount from high current tests on that loop without risking tripping any RCD (even if it's only monitoring the changes in voltage caused by other loads) - in 2 wire mode everything has to be done on the L-PE loop so tests might have to be slightly more agressive for the L-PE loop or repeated more times to get a plausible reading - all of which gives an RCBO extra chances to trip.


    I've also had problems using 3-wire tests on some low rated (<=6A) RCBOs - seemingly (and annoyingly) they seem to be tripping on overcurrent rather than residual current - i.e. it's the :large currents on the L-N loop that's tripping them rather than the small L-PE test currents.


      - Andy.
Reply
  • 0
    I think most (usually A-type) RCBOs these days are much more sensitive to residual currents that aren't nice pure sine waves than the traditional AC type RCCBs. That makes life much harder for loop testers - it's difficult to get an accurately measurable change in voltage from a maximum 15mA leakage current - so they usually resort to all sorts of tricks to use larger currents for very short durations to try to work out the loop impedance. In 3-wire mode where the meter has access to the L-N voltage and L-N loop it can deduce a certain amount from high current tests on that loop without risking tripping any RCD (even if it's only monitoring the changes in voltage caused by other loads) - in 2 wire mode everything has to be done on the L-PE loop so tests might have to be slightly more agressive for the L-PE loop or repeated more times to get a plausible reading - all of which gives an RCBO extra chances to trip.


    I've also had problems using 3-wire tests on some low rated (<=6A) RCBOs - seemingly (and annoyingly) they seem to be tripping on overcurrent rather than residual current - i.e. it's the :large currents on the L-N loop that's tripping them rather than the small L-PE test currents.


      - Andy.
Children
No Data

Join us to get the best from IET EngX.

Joining EngX lets you personalise your experience so you stay up to date on the topics that interest you, plus you’ll be able to make connections who are looking to collaborate, exchange ideas and more.

Join us Not now

Community Rules & Guidelines