This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Reliance Upon Mechanical and Electro-mechanical Devices and Machines.

There have been concerns shown about the reliability of R.C.D.s in the past, and the cruise liner Viking Sky's engines and also this......

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPKJRikunJw


Z.
Parents
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member

    Zoomup:

    I am a firm believer in two series R.C.D.s in installations. If one fails or is a bit sticky the other should operate and clear a fault. I have personally found several R.C.D.s that were faulty in installations. Relying on just one R.C.D. is taking a bit of a gamble.


     



    You would probably be better off focusing on the bonding and then design for an increased effective CPC size - that way you have a combination of both passive and active safety. RCD's in series are effective from some faults, but not all faults - if you are thinking along these lines then it's important to ascertain the common mode failures


    That said, twice the expenditure on RCD's to save a very small number of people hardly seems worth it  - from a safety perspective


    Regards


    OMS
     

Reply
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member

    Zoomup:

    I am a firm believer in two series R.C.D.s in installations. If one fails or is a bit sticky the other should operate and clear a fault. I have personally found several R.C.D.s that were faulty in installations. Relying on just one R.C.D. is taking a bit of a gamble.


     



    You would probably be better off focusing on the bonding and then design for an increased effective CPC size - that way you have a combination of both passive and active safety. RCD's in series are effective from some faults, but not all faults - if you are thinking along these lines then it's important to ascertain the common mode failures


    That said, twice the expenditure on RCD's to save a very small number of people hardly seems worth it  - from a safety perspective


    Regards


    OMS
     

Children
No Data