This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Meter accuracy

I recently purchased 2 little voltmeters they look like the sort that would go in a control or instrument panel they are connected with just 2 wires which provide the operating supply ( they light up green and red) however the green  one states it will work between 20and 500 volts and the red one between 60 and 480 volts. When they are both on the green one indicates normally around 241 volts the red one shows 235 volts why the discrepancy I know it's not much but makes you wonder if one of them is lying. Secondly I've noticed that the green one tracks voltage changes faster than the red one and that a few times the green one jumps down to 238 then up to 241 multiple times while the red one stays the same and I think can see a slight flicker in my filament lamps when this is happening incidentally both meters are connected to the same plug  a 2 pin 5 amp one
Parents

  • How can these 3 F currents be flowing in the opposite direction to the main current? I just don't get it a current as to come from somewhere ie something has to create it so where does it come from? Perhaps I should ask are these currents real or just a mathematical thing

     




    Well the glib answer is that it is a mathematical thing,  in the  same way that volts and amps are a mathematical thing that allows us to measure and then predict the behaviour of systems, but what we have really is moving electrons and the fields and waves they produce to influence each other, probably.

    Butt you know that, I think, and it is not so helpful in this example.

    With a rectifier and capacitor power supply, what you really have is  almost no current for all the part of the sinewave that is less than the voltage on the capacitor, and then a sudden burp of current for the ten or 20 degrees of the cycle near the crest (as you note pos and neg crests, for a full wave rectifier like a bridge).

    So the current is very peaky near the crests of the incoming supply. By the same token , as there is less load near the zero crossing, and up the flanks until the current flows, the voltage is like a sinewave of a higer voltage at the sides, and then flat-topped as the current starts to flow.

    Now an arm wavy picture like this and photos of a scope are all very well but to allow us to deduce how much filtering we need to mitigate this, and hw these waveforms will affect transformer windings etc we need a description that can be mathematised.

    V = V0.sin(2pi.F.t)  is the basic sine wave as a function of time,  and if you were to make a spreadsheet of values of time and plot the result you would see our familiar  sine wave.

    V = V0.sin(3.2pi.F.t)  is the form of the 3F waveform.


    To make a model approximation to the rectifier voltage waveform you need  say 10% of the 3F

    V = V0(sin(2pi.F.t)  + 0.1 .sin(3.2pi.F.t) )


    But for the current you want cancellation at the low flanks and addition at the peaks,  so


    V = V0(sin(2pi.F.t)  + 0.1 .sin(3.2pi.F.t) )


    It is an approximation, for modelling use and not perfect. Consider the following circuits and waveforms, and see if it helps you tie up the maths with the physics.

    One 'realistic' circuit, and the rather idealised view of the models for voltage and current.

    Note the average load current is much lower than the peaks that only flow during  the sine wave crests.

    I have added some 'wiring resistance' so we can plot the current in it and the volts accross.
    fd54bdafc73f9fb088406ca7af3844a7-huge-3f_explain_diodes.png


    f6b77dbfda1d69d5dd75808b87529636-huge-3f_explain_voltage.png
    d67ecc46ca270256f431d2973c63eb2b-huge-3f_explain_current.png

     


Reply

  • How can these 3 F currents be flowing in the opposite direction to the main current? I just don't get it a current as to come from somewhere ie something has to create it so where does it come from? Perhaps I should ask are these currents real or just a mathematical thing

     




    Well the glib answer is that it is a mathematical thing,  in the  same way that volts and amps are a mathematical thing that allows us to measure and then predict the behaviour of systems, but what we have really is moving electrons and the fields and waves they produce to influence each other, probably.

    Butt you know that, I think, and it is not so helpful in this example.

    With a rectifier and capacitor power supply, what you really have is  almost no current for all the part of the sinewave that is less than the voltage on the capacitor, and then a sudden burp of current for the ten or 20 degrees of the cycle near the crest (as you note pos and neg crests, for a full wave rectifier like a bridge).

    So the current is very peaky near the crests of the incoming supply. By the same token , as there is less load near the zero crossing, and up the flanks until the current flows, the voltage is like a sinewave of a higer voltage at the sides, and then flat-topped as the current starts to flow.

    Now an arm wavy picture like this and photos of a scope are all very well but to allow us to deduce how much filtering we need to mitigate this, and hw these waveforms will affect transformer windings etc we need a description that can be mathematised.

    V = V0.sin(2pi.F.t)  is the basic sine wave as a function of time,  and if you were to make a spreadsheet of values of time and plot the result you would see our familiar  sine wave.

    V = V0.sin(3.2pi.F.t)  is the form of the 3F waveform.


    To make a model approximation to the rectifier voltage waveform you need  say 10% of the 3F

    V = V0(sin(2pi.F.t)  + 0.1 .sin(3.2pi.F.t) )


    But for the current you want cancellation at the low flanks and addition at the peaks,  so


    V = V0(sin(2pi.F.t)  + 0.1 .sin(3.2pi.F.t) )


    It is an approximation, for modelling use and not perfect. Consider the following circuits and waveforms, and see if it helps you tie up the maths with the physics.

    One 'realistic' circuit, and the rather idealised view of the models for voltage and current.

    Note the average load current is much lower than the peaks that only flow during  the sine wave crests.

    I have added some 'wiring resistance' so we can plot the current in it and the volts accross.
    fd54bdafc73f9fb088406ca7af3844a7-huge-3f_explain_diodes.png


    f6b77dbfda1d69d5dd75808b87529636-huge-3f_explain_voltage.png
    d67ecc46ca270256f431d2973c63eb2b-huge-3f_explain_current.png

     


Children
No Data