The IET is carrying out some important updates between 17-30 April and all of our websites will be view only. For more information, read this Announcement

This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Panelboard vs Switchpanel

Hi all,


As the title, I’m just wondering in the absence of a client spec when you would spec a switchpanel over a panelboard. Looking at the Schneider website they appear to do a panelboard rated up to 1600A @ 50ka breaking capacity 


1600A x 400 x 1.732 = 1108 KVA.

Thus making it suitable for the majority of installations requiring a 1MVA tx


My thinking currently is that I’m assuming you would use a switchpanel when:

- Outgoing supply rated above 630A

- A sensitive installation where if works need to be done the whole board doesn’t need to be turned off (form 4 etc)

- Multiple 400A/630A coming off making terminations impractical

- maybe when an ACB is required (but I suppose this could be a separate enclosure)


if I’ve missed anything please share, or if there’s a rule of thumb.


whilst we’re on the topic, is there a rule of thumb for sizing the LV room?


thanks in advance
Parents
  • In addition to the practicle reasons you mention, in my mind the main reason you would choose a switchboard over a panel board would be the forms of seperation.


    Although I personally see forms of seperation as a bit of a waste of mony, most contractors these days wont open a switchboard unless it has been completely isolated. Other than some very particular use cases (where working on or near live equipment can be justified), what is the benifit in having the various forms of seperation...?

Reply
  • In addition to the practicle reasons you mention, in my mind the main reason you would choose a switchboard over a panel board would be the forms of seperation.


    Although I personally see forms of seperation as a bit of a waste of mony, most contractors these days wont open a switchboard unless it has been completely isolated. Other than some very particular use cases (where working on or near live equipment can be justified), what is the benifit in having the various forms of seperation...?

Children
No Data