Lumen equivalents of halogen floods v Led

Andy C:

perspicacious:


I don't know how much a halogen lamp output deteriorates with life.

 

In some cases 100% every five minutes! ?

I've been replacing fluorescent lamps with LEDs in several buildings. Going on manufacturers so-called lumen figures I'm either going to be suffering from burnt retinas or groping around in the half light! In practice I've just gone ahead and swapped them over and generally been satisfied. For example we've recently changed a community hall over from 14 70W twin HF fluoros to 14 single 6ft 4000k LEDs. On paper the fluoros should be about 13k lumens total per fitting, the LEDs about 7k so I'd be thinking the light levels will be reduced. In practice the lighting levels in the hall appear to be the same. I did consider going for cooler temp LEDs such as 3000k to replicate the fluoro lighting but 4000k seems perfectly okay without the blueness you get with higher temps.

. . .

In my experience, LEDs on places like instrument panels do lose light output over a considerable number of years, and it is beginning to look the same for the high power ones.


The directional properties of the lamps come into consideration here. Most fluorescent tubes emit light equally upwards and downwards. (Directional ones have been made but never came into wide use.) A lot of the upward light will probably be lost, especially if fittings are not kept clean (and by my observations places like community halls do not attend well to such matters). Whereas LEDs tend to direct light downwards where it is wanted by design.


I personally do tend to take "equivalents" with a pinch of salt, and would always look to lumen output. As has been said elsewhere, illumination is measured in lux, but it would be impracticable for a lamp manufacture to attempt to quote this, because it depends on distance of lamp from surface and many other factors such as size of room, reflectivity of walls, efficiency of light fitting, etc.


4 000 K seems to be settling down as a popular value for places like community halls and similar meeting places, avoiding the yellow of tungsten light but not as "blue" as the 6 500 K "daylight" types, which some may see as "less cosy".

Andy C:

perspicacious:


I don't know how much a halogen lamp output deteriorates with life.

 

In some cases 100% every five minutes! ?

I've been replacing fluorescent lamps with LEDs in several buildings. Going on manufacturers so-called lumen figures I'm either going to be suffering from burnt retinas or groping around in the half light! In practice I've just gone ahead and swapped them over and generally been satisfied. For example we've recently changed a community hall over from 14 70W twin HF fluoros to 14 single 6ft 4000k LEDs. On paper the fluoros should be about 13k lumens total per fitting, the LEDs about 7k so I'd be thinking the light levels will be reduced. In practice the lighting levels in the hall appear to be the same. I did consider going for cooler temp LEDs such as 3000k to replicate the fluoro lighting but 4000k seems perfectly okay without the blueness you get with higher temps.

. . .

In my experience, LEDs on places like instrument panels do lose light output over a considerable number of years, and it is beginning to look the same for the high power ones.


The directional properties of the lamps come into consideration here. Most fluorescent tubes emit light equally upwards and downwards. (Directional ones have been made but never came into wide use.) A lot of the upward light will probably be lost, especially if fittings are not kept clean (and by my observations places like community halls do not attend well to such matters). Whereas LEDs tend to direct light downwards where it is wanted by design.


I personally do tend to take "equivalents" with a pinch of salt, and would always look to lumen output. As has been said elsewhere, illumination is measured in lux, but it would be impracticable for a lamp manufacture to attempt to quote this, because it depends on distance of lamp from surface and many other factors such as size of room, reflectivity of walls, efficiency of light fitting, etc.


4 000 K seems to be settling down as a popular value for places like community halls and similar meeting places, avoiding the yellow of tungsten light but not as "blue" as the 6 500 K "daylight" types, which some may see as "less cosy".