This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Emergency lighting query

Probably a 1st year apprentice question, but can you substitute a NiCd battery of the same voltage/capacity in place of a NiMh without creating charging problems?
Parents
  • Probably OK in an EM fitting as most designs do just have a mix of constant voltage and then constant current.

    If  you have the fitting beside you , and can you tell me the cell size or Ah rating, and then put a meter in series and measure the on-charge current, and I can advise better.


    The reverse, fitting a NimH cell where a NiCd  used to go is quite common, and usually very successful, except in applications that push the cell hard for fast discharge or fast re-charge.

    You may come unstuck if there is circuitry to report failing cells by measuring the cell impedance, as niCd are quite a bit 'droopier' on load, even when nothing is wrong, but having drooped, often have a higher short circuit current.

    mike
Reply
  • Probably OK in an EM fitting as most designs do just have a mix of constant voltage and then constant current.

    If  you have the fitting beside you , and can you tell me the cell size or Ah rating, and then put a meter in series and measure the on-charge current, and I can advise better.


    The reverse, fitting a NimH cell where a NiCd  used to go is quite common, and usually very successful, except in applications that push the cell hard for fast discharge or fast re-charge.

    You may come unstuck if there is circuitry to report failing cells by measuring the cell impedance, as niCd are quite a bit 'droopier' on load, even when nothing is wrong, but having drooped, often have a higher short circuit current.

    mike
Children
No Data