This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

The Graphs in Fig 3A4-6. What does the vertical part of the characteristic mean?

There is a problem with these graphs. What is it and how should it be corrected?
Parents
  • davezawadi (David Stone):

    OK  Andy, is that really what they mean? Please explain.


    The vertical bits? - that's how I read them at least - there's a discontinuity between the thermal and magnetic parts - so when the current is right on the boundary between the two (the tiniest fraction below 5x In for a B-type for example) the thing could operate either in thermal mode and take over 10s to open, or it could be in magnetic mode and take (anything up to) 0.1s.


    I know some mathematicians who would say that the vertical bit shouldn't really be drawn at all when there's a discontinuity - better to just leave a gap.


    Given in BS 7671 land we're not really interested in disconnection times of over 5s, the whole graph is seems of limited use anyway.


       - Andy.


Reply
  • davezawadi (David Stone):

    OK  Andy, is that really what they mean? Please explain.


    The vertical bits? - that's how I read them at least - there's a discontinuity between the thermal and magnetic parts - so when the current is right on the boundary between the two (the tiniest fraction below 5x In for a B-type for example) the thing could operate either in thermal mode and take over 10s to open, or it could be in magnetic mode and take (anything up to) 0.1s.


    I know some mathematicians who would say that the vertical bit shouldn't really be drawn at all when there's a discontinuity - better to just leave a gap.


    Given in BS 7671 land we're not really interested in disconnection times of over 5s, the whole graph is seems of limited use anyway.


       - Andy.


Children
No Data