This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Wiring Regulations Literary Question

Former Community Member
Former Community Member
Hello all, I wonder if someone can help me please?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltage_optimisation#Overvoltage

I'm trying to get a reference for a section in this wikipedia article to put in a report I'm writing but I can't find the original source. Under the "Common Power Quality Problems > Overvoltage" section there is a sentence that describes "A 230 V rated lamp used at 240 will achieve only 55% of its rated life". From the article I believe it is from the book "Commentary on IET Wiring Regulations 17th Edition" from 2016, ISBN 1849197652.


I have tried to find it in a library as I don't have £90 to drop on a new copy of it, just to see if it is this book I should be referencing in my report, but I've had no luck there. Is there perhaps anyone with this book that knows whether or not the quote does indeed come from it or not?


Any assistance with this query would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance

Alan
Parents
  • Even if it's mentioned in a Wiring Regulations Commentary, it would be better (in your writing) to quote a source whose authors specifically know about lighting.  So Mike's suggestion (a lighting book) or Dave's (a manufacturer specification) sound preferable even if the quoted text can be found in the Commentary.


    If you're able to access this book (Handbook of advanced lighting technology) you'll find somewhere halfway down the introduction chapter the text  "The life of incandescent lamps varies inversely as the 13th power of the applied voltage.  Voltage 10 % below rated increases incandescent lamp life by a factor 3.5 over rated; 10 % above, a corresponding factor 3.5 reduction in life."


    Whether it's the "13th power" - or a bit more or less - depends on the particular lamp or the person you ask. This old article (The life-voltage exponent for tungsten lamps, Covington 1973) should be a very good source, but I can't access more than the first page. The exponent can also vary when moving away from rated voltage.

    The 55% of lifetime that you mention suggests instead an exponent more like 14, because:  1 / (240/230)^14 =~ 0.55. But it doesn't make much difference: with an exponent of 13 it's about 58% ...  it's anyway a big change in lifetime or light output, for not many percent in voltage.

Reply
  • Even if it's mentioned in a Wiring Regulations Commentary, it would be better (in your writing) to quote a source whose authors specifically know about lighting.  So Mike's suggestion (a lighting book) or Dave's (a manufacturer specification) sound preferable even if the quoted text can be found in the Commentary.


    If you're able to access this book (Handbook of advanced lighting technology) you'll find somewhere halfway down the introduction chapter the text  "The life of incandescent lamps varies inversely as the 13th power of the applied voltage.  Voltage 10 % below rated increases incandescent lamp life by a factor 3.5 over rated; 10 % above, a corresponding factor 3.5 reduction in life."


    Whether it's the "13th power" - or a bit more or less - depends on the particular lamp or the person you ask. This old article (The life-voltage exponent for tungsten lamps, Covington 1973) should be a very good source, but I can't access more than the first page. The exponent can also vary when moving away from rated voltage.

    The 55% of lifetime that you mention suggests instead an exponent more like 14, because:  1 / (240/230)^14 =~ 0.55. But it doesn't make much difference: with an exponent of 13 it's about 58% ...  it's anyway a big change in lifetime or light output, for not many percent in voltage.

Children
No Data