Why would an electrician install a 10 mm twin and earth circuit protected by a B32 MCB for a 8.5 kW shower?
Why would an electrician install a 10 mm twin and earth circuit protected by a B32 MCB for a 8.5 kW shower?
I see no part of BS7671 that says a 32A breaker may not be fitted, although it may be slightly unwise from a convenience point of view. Andy, you are putting forward slightly odd views, the case size of a 63A breaker is the same as a 32A one, so why do you think it may “overheat”? That is exactly what its thermal section is supposed to do to switch off small overloads, and the actual heat load for all sizes is exactly the same! You are falling into the “I don't like the look of that” trap, you may not but it is not dangerous in any way, and if the breaker trips, that is exactly what it is designed to do. I suspect too that Andy J is missing a point, the faster trip time is fairly unlikely as the thermal section is pretty accurate, because it also needs to be very repeatable, and there is no advantage this being quick, although there may be for the magnetic part as contact wear will be reduced. As usual, the question brings up many other pieces of knowledge and information that are largely unconsidered.
I see no part of BS7671 that says a 32A breaker may not be fitted, although it may be slightly unwise from a convenience point of view. Andy, you are putting forward slightly odd views, the case size of a 63A breaker is the same as a 32A one, so why do you think it may “overheat”? That is exactly what its thermal section is supposed to do to switch off small overloads, and the actual heat load for all sizes is exactly the same! You are falling into the “I don't like the look of that” trap, you may not but it is not dangerous in any way, and if the breaker trips, that is exactly what it is designed to do. I suspect too that Andy J is missing a point, the faster trip time is fairly unlikely as the thermal section is pretty accurate, because it also needs to be very repeatable, and there is no advantage this being quick, although there may be for the magnetic part as contact wear will be reduced. As usual, the question brings up many other pieces of knowledge and information that are largely unconsidered.
We're about to take you to the IET registration website. Don't worry though, you'll be sent straight back to the community after completing the registration.
Continue to the IET registration site