This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

What do you consider a sample to mean during an EICR

I’m interested to hear peoples opinions on how they approach an EICR with regards to a sample? I’m asking because I was recently reviewing a couple of domestic EICRs for a client and raised a couple of questions one being that test results were only recorded for two of the six circuits. The response was that they were employed only to carry out a 20% sample. Personally I’ve always considered a 20% sample to mean that all circuits should be tested but only at 20% of the accessories connected to them will be fully tested and inspected. I’ve also always thought when carrying out an EICR for the purposes of private lettings that this practice is only an option when the previous records are available, and if you do choose to carry out a small sample you’d be likely to widen the search if you found any C2’s or C1s. What is everyone’s thoughts here, how does the community approach EICRs?

I was just surprised to see an unsatisfactory report where the sample hadn’t been widened and where four circuits had no test results recorded, not even Insulation resistance, it’s so quick getting IR results on a single phase board.

Parents
  • The first thing I need to mention is you do not sample circuits, you inspect and test all the circuits. You don't sample PA Test a number of appliances and then pronounce all the appliances to be satisfactory on that basis.

    If you have a large building you may I&T say 20% of the boards each year over 5 years to spread the cost and disruption but all the boards get I&T in that cycle. All DBs and all circuits get inspected and tested.

    You need to separate out the 2 processes, inspection and testing. BS 7671 Chapter 65 sets out the objective for a Periodic Inspection and Test. It majors on inspection, not testing.

    You can sample inspect items on each circuit say 20% of accessories on a circuit by removing them and having a look behind and checking the tightness of terminations.

    You can sample test say by testing all readily accessible sockets and 20% of light fittings on a circuit.

    As I have said in my post above if you want my standard specification for a MINIMUM standard for inspecting and testing a dwelling I will send it to you free with no strings attached. 

  • 652.2 comes to mind.

    So, the "electrical installation" of 651.1 does not necessarily mean the WHOLE building. (See definitions).

    Z.

Reply
  • 652.2 comes to mind.

    So, the "electrical installation" of 651.1 does not necessarily mean the WHOLE building. (See definitions).

    Z.

Children
No Data