This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

MCB Change on Socket Circuit - No RCD

Hello All,

I have a question which I'm sure will have lots of opinions, so look forward to hearing them. 

After having carried out an EICR some welding sockets have failed, some due to the size of the MCB in relation to the cables current carrying capacity and some due to Zs. The loading is not an issue so we are looking to downgrade the size of the breakers which will sort out both issues. However as these are feeding sockets if we change the MCB will these have to become RCD protected. Although they have a specific intended use I cannot guarantee they wouldn't be used for anything else. However due to cost implications the customer is not willing to pay for either 3 phase RCBO's or individual RCD's mounted by the board or for replacing the sockets to include RCD's. By the changing the MCB we would only be making the circuit safer and up to the standard when it was installed, however I would usually try and bring any circuit I work on up to current standards. But as there are about 8 three phase circuits affected its not a simple or cheap option to replace them all. 

Look forward to any opinions or articles relating to this matter.

Thank you 

Bees 

Parents
  • What Code did you apply for lack of RCD protection when you prepared the EICR?

  • The lack of RCD was coded as C3 and the failure for max zs was recorded as C2

Reply
  • The lack of RCD was coded as C3 and the failure for max zs was recorded as C2

Children
No Data