This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Two way+intermediate domestic light circuit extraneous voltage head scratching

Hi my house is supplied via T-T system, the pole mounted mains transformer is 100mts away,

the measured Ze is 120ohms

on a two way+intermediate circuit I’m measuring 60-90vac when the light is in any off position,

I have disconnected all circuit wires and it all measured clear, the circuit is blowing led lamps and fluorescent lamps are pulsing when in off positions, any ideas!!!

  • what is the input impedance of the meter you are measureing to 60-90v with - note that 3c/earth cable has 50-100pf/ metre of core to core capacitance, and that is in effect in shunt with the off switch, so the voltage never falls to zero.

    If a conventional resistive filament lamp causes the voltage to fall to zero, you could consider adding 0.1uF or so in parallel with the lamps so that in the off state there is ~ 100:1 capacitive voltage division.
    Mike.

  • Almost certainly capacitive coupling between an always live wire and the switched live to the lamps. The degree of such capacitive coupling will depend upon the circuit layout and cable lengths. Often called induction, but capacitive coupling is a more accurate description.

    I would be surprised if the phenomena was destroying the lamps. More likely cheap lamps that fail early.

    The only simple cure is to shunt the lamps with a small MAINS RATED capacitor such as a small power factor correction capacitor as used in fluorescent lamp circuits.

  • Hi Mike, I received my capacitor today and fitted it as suggested and the voltage has dropped to 3vac, I think it’s a result and all is working ok.

    regards

    colin

  • Hi broardgage, I have fitted a 0.1microfarad ac capacitor as suggested and the voltage is now 3vac, I think that’s a result and all is now working ok.

    colin

  • Good to hear that has cracked it. In the old days of filament lamps and moving coil meters that actually took some current to move the needle, we never saw these effects, as the addition of the slightest real load caused the voltage to just  collapse. However the effect was always there to a greater or lesser extent. Now with electronics that starts to do things at lower currents, with fractions of a mA in some cases, the effect of wiring capacitance is more obvious. One of the funniest  I had was a misfiring Worcester Bosch boiler that would come on when it was supposed to be off, but not very often.  In that case a cap between the 'fire now' line from the thermostats and so on, pulling down to neutral, calmed it down so it was no longer 'haunted' !

    A capacitor 'load' is a lot cooler and more convenient to fit in a back box or whatever than a resistor - of course just watch the voltage rating, and do not fit too much capacitance - lots of uF lead to a risk of storing a lethal charge if while you are testing things the capacitor gets isolated at the crest of a wave, and unnecessarily large currents circulating when the system is in operation. If you go really mad with tens of uF the in rush of charging the capacitor can shorten the life of light switches etc .

    In my experience 0.1uF is a good size for any wiring of less than and upto perhaps 100m long. If you  ever need to do a massive warehouse or something you may need more than one.... (there are also 'snubbers' made to take the edge off arcing motors that are a cap and a small series resistor of hundred ohms or so in an encapsulated blob, and  these can also be pressed into service in the 'anti-flicker' role as well as motor suppression (examples ) if you are ever up a creek without paddle again.)

    One to salt away in the book of useful tricks and dodges.

    Mike

  • My Schneider Volt stick sometimes gives false positives where supposedly dead cables run parallel to live cables where the live cable(s) induces a current in the supposedly dead cables.

    A test lamp is a good way to double check.

    Drummond MTL1000 Spare Bulb - Martindale Electric (martindale-electric.co.uk)

    Z.

  • Of course a cheapskate like me puts a dummy load on it and uses the modern voltage testers (great care needed though)