EICR TT installation coded C2 by electrician

Hi,


Anybody got any thoughts on this situation?

I have had an EICR done on a property. There were no issues reported apart from earthing. 

The electrician measured the rod resistance at 534 ohms. He insists it has to be less than 200, but his preference is less than a 100.
He said the 30ma RCD wouldn't trip at the measured value, so didn't bother to test it. Bizarrely, he said he pressed the test button which, of course, tripped, but he coded it C2 "unsatisfactory".

I had already tested it with my meter. I got 400ohms, a worst case trip time of 9ms, best 6ms and 28ma on the ramp test.

I pointed out the 200ohms is a recommendation not a requirement and asked him to justify his C2, he refused and stated he stands by his findings.

I haven't checked yet if there is an obvious reason for the rod to be high, but it seems to me the requirements of the regulations have been met.


Parents
  • At 534 ohms, the Ra is well within 7671 requirements, but is the value stable and reliable? Might there be a reason why it is relatively high, is it in to loose soil, poorly connected etc?
    The Ra at my own house was around 300 ohms when last tested but I have made several tests over the years and was able to confirm that it was a consistent result. 
    I live in the foothills of the Mourne mountains with rock bursting through parts of the garden, not so good for sinking rods. 

Reply
  • At 534 ohms, the Ra is well within 7671 requirements, but is the value stable and reliable? Might there be a reason why it is relatively high, is it in to loose soil, poorly connected etc?
    The Ra at my own house was around 300 ohms when last tested but I have made several tests over the years and was able to confirm that it was a consistent result. 
    I live in the foothills of the Mourne mountains with rock bursting through parts of the garden, not so good for sinking rods. 

Children
  • The ground is well compacted. The rod is close to the house wall driven down the side of the concrete yard. The houses are well over 100 years old and have no footings and also the ground is about 2 ft lower than the garden to the rear which is chippings so free to drain. There is no chance it could freeze or dry out under the concrete, except in exceptionally severe weather.  The area is pretty flat and below the soil there is a lot of sand. I have three other properties within 100M and they about 100 ohms or lower. I haven't checked yet, but I'd be more inclined to suspect the termination on the rod.