"it is that pesky SY braided stuff again; so what's wrong with it"

More a discussion come question perhaps, but are there any really good reasons why a choice of SY would be made for a fixed wire low voltage power circuit  over something else ?

My understanding of the braiding,  is that it has nothing to do with armouring and is not acceptable as armouring;  but is it still an exposed conductive part to be earthed and if it is not [earthed], how much of a risk  ?

from reading Eland (who have a pdf on the SY stuff) to mention one manufacturer, is that it is a somewhat standards tested cable (https://www.elandcables.com/media/13rlt2rk/ec-statement-on-the-use-of-sy-cy-yy-cables-rina-18th-ed-with-summary.pdf)

In the case observed being a 3phs circuit, it was 5core (one as cpc) from a metal db (through plastic stuffing gland) to a plastic interlock socket, 16a 3pole mcb and it appeared the braiding was unterminated.   it was not on a run likely to be disturbed.   Nothing noted on the EIC about its use either.

regards

Habs

Parents
  • what I would be coming to as a conclusion is,  installation choice (EIC record of deviation or not), when it comes to inspections, is it really an issue though if it is used and what is a fair observation of it ... however if a non-standard is used how can it be assessed and what against and so on  to lead to a safety observation.

    in the case I described what would the outcome be !   line up 100 electricians and what would be the prevailing opinion

Reply
  • what I would be coming to as a conclusion is,  installation choice (EIC record of deviation or not), when it comes to inspections, is it really an issue though if it is used and what is a fair observation of it ... however if a non-standard is used how can it be assessed and what against and so on  to lead to a safety observation.

    in the case I described what would the outcome be !   line up 100 electricians and what would be the prevailing opinion

Children
No Data