Earthing and bonding, possible island mode, why separate earths.

Looking at a domestic install, have only looked at earthing in the meter cabinet so far.

It's a single phase installation with solar on the roof of a detached stables. At the moment not quite sure how the solar is connected in to the main system, needs further investigation tomorrow, but I don't think it's likely to support island mode.

The bit that's confusing me at tge moment is earthing in the meter cabinet.

There's a TNC's earth coming of the supply, going in to the house

There is also a TT earth connected in to a Henley block along with a bunch of what I assume are bonding conductors and another main earth going in to the house. But the TT earth and the TNC';s earth are not visibly connected in the meter box. They may be connected somewhere else, still need to investigate. But why would the installer separate the two earthing systems? Even if island mode is supported in the installation from what I have read just line a neutral are switched and all the earthing remains connected.

I am installing an EV charger. At the moment my plan would be to a bit more investigation but ultimately will just connect the TNCS and TT earth together and to the EV db.

Any thoughts on the arrangement and best course of action.

Thanks

  • Hard to say without seeing it. TT might be TN-C-S with an additional electrode, or as there are stables (if actually used for livestock) might well need a TT system itself (in which case interconnecting with PME would be a bad idea). Not sure why both are mixed at the meter cabinet - Is the meter cabinet at the stables?

       - Andy.

  • I am installing an EV charger. At the moment my plan would be to a bit more investigation but ultimately will just connect the TNCS and TT earth together and to the EV db.

    As Andy says, difficult to tell without seeing the installation. I would be very wary of simply connecting the two without checking the island mode design through fully, because depending on how the inverter is arranged, the you might just "re-earth" a neutral in the installation, which is potentially a breach of ESQCR, and might cause unwanted operation of RCDs in the installation. It would effectively be an 'N-E fault'.

    But ... leaving them separated could potentially cause problems, because I'm sure you're aware that BS 7671 requires simultaneously accessible exposed-conductive-parts to be connected to the same earthing system where ADS is used (Reg 411.3.1.1).

    There are apparently a number of inverters out there at the moment that offer so-called "island mode" or "power backup" which cannot be installed according to the UK's installation standards/requirements and UK industry guidance for installations, in respect of that functionality.

    Just one example of differences in approach internationally, is that a PME type system is used in other countries in Europe, such as Germany.

    • In Germany, there is no problem relying on the N-PE connection at the origin of the installation, and most installations already have an earth electrode (foundation earth electrode), and I believe that island mode is simply achieved in Germany by disconnecting the line conductors from the grid.
    • Not so in the UK, where we have Regulation 551.4.3.2.1 (can't rely on distributor's means of earthing for switched alternative supplies, i.e. island mode) simply because the N-PE connection and the earthing of the PEN is wholly outside the installation and the consumer's control. So our island mode approach (supported by G98/G99, which by virtue of Regulations 21 and 22 of ESQCR are effectively mandatory where they apply as it provides the "distributor's requirements" mentioned in the legislation) is to disconnect all live conductors (including Neutral) and then re-reference the Neutral by closing a 'N-E Bond Relay' or 'System Referencing Relay' (reverse procedure when returning to connected mode).
  • Hi All

    Thanks for the input. Turns out there wasn't anything as cleaver as island mode installed, just a very bad conversion from TT earthing to TNC-S. The installer had made the TNC-S connection through to the main DB, but only to the main DB using a 6mm cable. The TT earth was connected only through supplementary bonding in the bathroom. I don't think the stables are used for live stock, but couldn't gain access to make further checks on my last visit. Strange arrangement where they are using power from the house and also providing solar power to the house but not owned by the householders. House was sold without the attached land and stables.