Two Distribution boards supplied by one sub-main

I'm in the middle of a 'discussion' over an EICR in which the contractor is claiming that two distribution boards (in different parts of the building) but fed from the same sub-main (well, split on the outgoing terminals of the supplying switch fuse) is a C2 and needs to be changed.

He is unwilling to supply a regulation which he feels this contravenes and I'm struggling to find such a reg.

What is the opinion of the learned community?

I think this is perhaps not best practice but I'm struggling with his assertion of a C2.

Comments please...... 

Parents
  • Thanks for all the replies so far.....

    So, some more detail....

    The installation is commercial. The supply is 230/400V at 400A. After tariff metering, the supply passes through a main switch & into a 500A busbar chamber.

    Connected to the busbars are around a dozen 3 phase switchfuses which supply various distribution boards around this small/medium sized factory.

    The switchfuse in question contains 80A BS88 fuses and has two sets of 35mm^2 lugged onto each of the bolt-on lug terminals (one on the front, one on the rear). The submains are in SWA, glanded into trunking run above the switchfuses and each goes off to service a 12 way TPN board that supplies general light & power.  Although the boards are separate (by around 15m) they do service the same general area. There is no evidence of overloading or thermal distress in the BS88 fuses & the fuses have never blown. There are no heavy loads connected to either board - the biggest MCB present in either board being 32A TP (supplying ceeform sockets).

    My thoughts are pretty much inline with you you are all saying: while perhaps not the best in terms of design it doesn't actually warrant a code at all.

Reply
  • Thanks for all the replies so far.....

    So, some more detail....

    The installation is commercial. The supply is 230/400V at 400A. After tariff metering, the supply passes through a main switch & into a 500A busbar chamber.

    Connected to the busbars are around a dozen 3 phase switchfuses which supply various distribution boards around this small/medium sized factory.

    The switchfuse in question contains 80A BS88 fuses and has two sets of 35mm^2 lugged onto each of the bolt-on lug terminals (one on the front, one on the rear). The submains are in SWA, glanded into trunking run above the switchfuses and each goes off to service a 12 way TPN board that supplies general light & power.  Although the boards are separate (by around 15m) they do service the same general area. There is no evidence of overloading or thermal distress in the BS88 fuses & the fuses have never blown. There are no heavy loads connected to either board - the biggest MCB present in either board being 32A TP (supplying ceeform sockets).

    My thoughts are pretty much inline with you you are all saying: while perhaps not the best in terms of design it doesn't actually warrant a code at all.

Children
No Data