Hotel External Lighting - RCD

Good afternoon

We have some bollards and lighting columns at the backyard of a hotel

We are feeding them with XLPE/SWA/LSF cables through ducts.

Do we need RCD protection at the board?

I am looking into BS7671 section 714 - OUTDOOR LIGHTING INSTALLATION and there doesnt seem to be anything to indicate an RCD apart from a telephone kiosk, bus shelter, advertising panels and town plans.

Do I read it correct or having a steel column makes a difference and I do need an RCD?

I wouldnt normally ask however I remember in the past people in here pointing out that the external lights need RCD and refer to some BS7671 clause but my memory isnt that good

Thanks

Parents
  • Something like the below

    714.411.3.4 Additional protection
    Lighting that is accessible to the public shall have additional protection by an RCD having the characteristics specified in Regulation 415.1.1
    Examples include:
    1. Gardens, spaces open to the public
    2. Telephone kiosks
    3. Bus shelters
    4. Advertising panels and town plans
    This list is not exhaustive.
    The following are excluded:
    5. Street lighting and traffic signage
    6. Illumination of monuments
    7. Platform lighting at rail/bus stations.

    In view of the above quoted regulation, it could be argued that RCD protection is needed for certain types of car park lighting, especially bollards, which are easily damaged by cars and vandalism

    IIRC it was 18th edition BS7671 amendment 2 after child got electrocuted in the pub beer garden 

  • Appropriate Regulation referenced above by  

    Some more background as to why you ought to provide the RCD, regardless of what BS 7671 says, is provided in the information and advice from the HSE here: press.hse.gov.uk/.../

    Further to all of that, BS 7671 is a minimum standard - there are particular use-cases for spaces open to the public, major infrastructure, workplaces, etc., where additional measures may be required depending on risk assessment (including CDM risk assessment, as pretty much all electrical installation work, including maintenance, is classified as construction work in CDM).

  • mind you that pub had so much wrong with it that an accident was waiting to happen - the wiring to the outside lights was utterly negligent, but so were many other aspects it was quite a catalogue.

    An RCD may well have saved the youngster, if he was well grounded, but I'd not like to suggest that an RCD magically makes that sort of installation standard OK in the UK.

    The alternate view for  your lights question is how dangerous does it become if the RCD trips due to a none- fault event and is not reset fairly smartly afterwards ?

    I'd consider a few bollards (as it sounds like) going off and staying off all night, not to be an issue, so long as there is other lighting, but if it also plunges into darkness, say the only illumination for a narrow set of uneven stone steps or something, there is also a counter safety case for keeping at least some of the lights on - as there is for streetlights on main roads. This may not apply here however but is a more general comment.

    Mike

  • Thanks

    Number 1 was not in BS7679 Amendment 1

    I just checked and it is now in amendment 2

    So this looks to be a recent thing. Am I right?

    Basically as I understand the principle behind this....ANY metal furniture/electrical item outside that can come in contact with public should be under RCD.

    For example I have a PTZ Camera on metal pole that needs power supply.

    I am thinking it should be on RCD as well under the same principle.

    At least that's how I see it after this list of items you have posted

  • A further thought to this scenario could be a 240v supply via RCD to the center of the carpark to a pillar/column/cabinet and then 36v or 48v to the lights.  This would allow for each light to be on its own radial circuit for testing/maintenance and isolation.  The cabinet/pillar could have some extra protection like perimeter barriers 50cm to 100cm beyond the cabinet as it a car park.  Cable length and volt drop would need to be calculated if 36v/48v is used as there are limits on the length. 

Reply
  • A further thought to this scenario could be a 240v supply via RCD to the center of the carpark to a pillar/column/cabinet and then 36v or 48v to the lights.  This would allow for each light to be on its own radial circuit for testing/maintenance and isolation.  The cabinet/pillar could have some extra protection like perimeter barriers 50cm to 100cm beyond the cabinet as it a car park.  Cable length and volt drop would need to be calculated if 36v/48v is used as there are limits on the length. 

Children
No Data