Do CPS schemes like NICEIC and NAPIT have a duty of care to get their members over the line?

Do CPS (Competent Person Schemes)like NICEIC and NAPIT have a duty of care to get their members over the line?


Qualifications Guide (June 2025) for EAS Appendix 4 - Mandatory Technical Competence Requirements by Work Category
Produced by The Electrotechnical Skills Partnership
on behalf of the EAS Management Committee

Should the CPS be helping their members meet the requirements for EAS in the correct way?
Do the CPS even know the statistics for which of their members meet the requirements?
What about Non-CPS members, will they by default lose their title of electrician even if they have been doing the job for twenty or so years?

The UK electrical industry as a whole needs to increase its numbers but it seems there are many people who will fall foul of the system which means they will have to take complex routes to maintain their status as an electrician.  There are many electricians out there in the UK who do not own/possess a gold card or the requirements for a gold card.  

In my opinion I think that the CPS and industry as a whole have duty of care to work on a system that helps get the people that are 3/4 or less qualified to the qualifies status without it being a massive financial burden on the electrician itself.  As an example there are several well know YouTube electricians who don't have an NVQ but they have many hours of video showing their work, thus industry lead body or representative should asses their skill and convert the hours of YouTube videos (other social media platforms are available) into the NVQ and get them one stage close to Gold Card status.  

If the industry and the CPS do not help it members then there will be a very accelerated natural attrition of the UK electrician because when they go and renew the next membership or BS7671 19th edition they will no longer meet the requirements for entry of that course or membership. 


I do understand the reason for having the EAS showing the requirements for title/role but whole construction and engineer industry needs to help.  I recently heard of a plasterer who was teaching and working but was refused a a certification card for their trade.  

I wonder how many Electrical tutors there are in FE colleges in the UK?  Of those how many are fully qualified as an Electrician according to the EAS so that they are qualified to teach the courses?  I suspect it is highly possible that some tutors may need to sit there AM2 and/or produce a NVQ portfolio.




As always please be polite and respectful in this purely academic debate.





Come on everybody let’s help inspire the future.

  • More and more are no longer prepared to keep taking the overprescribed medicine.

    Stick with this - there are too many valid points in this video to list from memory.

    www.youtube.com/watch

  • I feel his pain, but he is rather gobby.

    Why would he need a CPS? He is is probably making far more from YouTube than he ever did on the tools.

  • I feel his pain, but he is rather gobby.

    David very much has his "finger on the pulse" of a lot of UK electricians

    Why would he need a CPS? He is is probably making far more from YouTube than he ever did on the tools.

    David makes minimal money from YouTube as his language marks him down on the YT algorithm.  (some say this is intentional as a form of copywright protection).  HOWEVER if you watch his videos (and there are many over the years) you will see that his electrical knowledge is very high, if you were to ask 10,000 UK electricians if they think he was competent they would all answer with a resounding YES to the point that many of his videos are actually education.  

  • if you were to ask 10,000 UK electricians if they think he was competent they would all answer with a resounding YES

    Agreed.

    I think he makes a very valid point about assessments. Whether they demonstrate anything is another matter. Lawyers and doctors also have to do them, but known as "appraisals". Naturally, everybody is on their best behaviourl and puts in their best effort, so are they truly representative?