Electricians need to live in the real world

“Electricians need to live in the real world”. That was the response by a chief examiner from City and Guilds to a question posed by the IET’s own doyen of sartorial elegance, Mr Mark Coles when he asked the chief examiner if electronic copies of BS7671 could be used in future exams. “Oh no” said the chief examiner, “electricians need to understand how to source information from the book.” Perhaps what he meant to say was that City and Guilds are very protective of a well-embedded revenue stream and that any attempt to facilitate online exams using the electronic book would require a complete and expensive engine change. Anyway, moving forward, its the paper version of the 7671 for those sparks living in the real world!

It wasn’t apparent if Mr Coles agreed with the chief examiner, but in his effort not to be contrary, but without being deferential, Mr Coles had the last word, “ah well, maybe some time in the future”. At least that will offer a tiny glimmer of hope for us sparks who do not live in the real world!

Parents
  • Maybe the chief examiner from City and Guilds could get in the 'real world' and explore adding relevant criteria to courses like 2391 for 

    1 Modern Safety Devices
        •    AFDDs (Arc Fault Detection Devices): Understanding their function, correct circuit placement, and how to evaluate and code the absence of AFDDs on an Electrical Installation Condition Report (EICR).
        •    SPDs (Surge Protection Devices): Checking surge protection coordination, inspecting for type 1, 2, and 3 SPDs, and validating their operational status. 

    2. Smart Home and Modern Load Requirements
        •    Smart and Bi-directional Devices: Testing considerations for microgeneration and distributed energy resources.
        •    Electric Underfloor Heating & Heat Pumps: Inspection of localized supplementary bonding and specialized control circuits.

    I am sure many people on this forum know of C & G courses / Books that are in need of an update.  

    Interestingly enough my web search engin brought this up 

    Does the humble C&G-2391 syllabus need to be updated?

    engx.theiet.org/.../does-the-humble-c-g-2391-syllabus-need-to-be-updated

    That was something I wrote almost a year ago.  

Reply
  • Maybe the chief examiner from City and Guilds could get in the 'real world' and explore adding relevant criteria to courses like 2391 for 

    1 Modern Safety Devices
        •    AFDDs (Arc Fault Detection Devices): Understanding their function, correct circuit placement, and how to evaluate and code the absence of AFDDs on an Electrical Installation Condition Report (EICR).
        •    SPDs (Surge Protection Devices): Checking surge protection coordination, inspecting for type 1, 2, and 3 SPDs, and validating their operational status. 

    2. Smart Home and Modern Load Requirements
        •    Smart and Bi-directional Devices: Testing considerations for microgeneration and distributed energy resources.
        •    Electric Underfloor Heating & Heat Pumps: Inspection of localized supplementary bonding and specialized control circuits.

    I am sure many people on this forum know of C & G courses / Books that are in need of an update.  

    Interestingly enough my web search engin brought this up 

    Does the humble C&G-2391 syllabus need to be updated?

    engx.theiet.org/.../does-the-humble-c-g-2391-syllabus-need-to-be-updated

    That was something I wrote almost a year ago.  

Children
No Data