The IET is carrying out some important updates between 17-30 April and all of our websites will be view only. For more information, read this Announcement

Rules and Guidelines
Want to participate in the discussions? Please read our Community Rules and Guidelines. Need some help? Visit Support and Answers.

  • State Not Answered
  • Locked Locked
  • Replies 16 replies
  • Subscribers 31 subscribers
  • Views 14071 views
  • Users 0 members are here
Options
You may also be interested in
This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Using RCBO to overcome high Zs but what about short circuits?

Sparkymania
This is something that occurred to me a while ago.

If the Zs is too high for the breaker to operate we ether install a downrated breaker is possible or an RCBO.

My supervisor said something about if an RCBO was installed for this reason then having to test for PSCC at the end of circuit but couldn't say why. He had been told this by NICEIC but no explanation as to why. I argued that this didn't make sense as PFC is only needed at the point where the protective device is and if it's lower at the DB than that of the PD then it will be even lower the further you go down the circuit. I've seen a video that has explained the reason. It's the current flow to trip the breaker on a short circuit rather than an earth fault. Obvious really when you think about it.

However, why would you use a max Zs for line to earth to make sure the resistance allows current flow to trip a breaker for a line to earth fault but not use the same for a line to neutral fault? Surely the impedances would be the same. You already have the max Zs to hand in many tables. With the PSCC you have to calculate what current is needed to trip the breaker or check the tables in the regs. Why do it one way for one and the other way for the other?

Therefore, if you had a C32 MCB with max Zs of 0.54 that would be the same for the line to neutral impedance. Why not just do a Ze then a Z line-neutral.

I see a problem with this as well. RCBOs are often used for higher measured Zs than max Zs if the breaker can't be downrated. But a lot of the time the impedance between line and earth and line and neutral can be almost the same and in a circuit wired with the same size CPC both impedances can be the same. So using and RCD to overcome Zs that's over the max still leaves a problem with a short circuit. This is never taken into account.

This is more an issue with thermal contraints than with shock protection.


I searched the post but couldn't find anything with this subject, although it might be there and I've used the wrong search words.
Parents
  • 0

    broadgage:

    As an extreme but illustrative example consider a circuit wired in 2.5mm SWA without any de-rating for grouping etc, and protected by a 20 amp fuse. If the cable was long enough, the fuse might never operate on a phase to neutral short circuit. But would the cable be damaged? I suspect not.

    In most real world cases voltage drop would be a problem first.




    It wouldn't do much for your leccy bill would it? ?


    But yes, it's a fair point.


    I have to admit that it took me a while to realise that an RCD won't clear a short circuit, but an RCBO might. IMHO the OP's concern is justified. Good design would require that a short circuit would trip promptly.

Reply
  • 0

    broadgage:

    As an extreme but illustrative example consider a circuit wired in 2.5mm SWA without any de-rating for grouping etc, and protected by a 20 amp fuse. If the cable was long enough, the fuse might never operate on a phase to neutral short circuit. But would the cable be damaged? I suspect not.

    In most real world cases voltage drop would be a problem first.




    It wouldn't do much for your leccy bill would it? ?


    But yes, it's a fair point.


    I have to admit that it took me a while to realise that an RCD won't clear a short circuit, but an RCBO might. IMHO the OP's concern is justified. Good design would require that a short circuit would trip promptly.

Children
No Data

Join us to get the best from IET EngX.

Joining EngX lets you personalise your experience so you stay up to date on the topics that interest you, plus you’ll be able to make connections who are looking to collaborate, exchange ideas and more.

Join us Not now

Community Rules & Guidelines