The IET is carrying out some important updates between 17-30 April and all of our websites will be view only. For more information, read this Announcement

This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

BS 8519

Hello,


I understand that the standard identifies the need for a dedicated containment for the fire rated life safety circuits. I assume this is so the normal circuits (non fire rated) will not compromise the integrity of the life safety circuits in case of fire (eg normal circuits will be on fire before the fire rated circuits which will be next to them if they were installed on the same containment).


But wouldn’t the same happen with the cpcs of the life safety circuits that are not fire rated?


Furthermore, is it ok to install on the same containment a circuit with 30 mins fire survival time (eg fire alarms) along with a circuit of 1 or 2h fire survival time (eg disabled refuge)?


I was under the impression that the fire survival time of a circuit is based on its wickest component but this does not always seem to be the case since the cpc are installed in the same containment.


It would be appreciated if you could share your thoughts.
Parents
  • I think the idea of seperate containment is/can be a problem.

    A tray with dividers - are the divisions seperate containers? well the 2,3,4 channels might be but the overall trough isn`t.

    There again completely seperate trays held by the same struts etc could be just as onerous.

    Taking it further to another (silly) conclusion, a whole area/room/building is a "container".

    You need to not only read the particulare reg(s) but also it`s intention of how far we mitigate risks
Reply
  • I think the idea of seperate containment is/can be a problem.

    A tray with dividers - are the divisions seperate containers? well the 2,3,4 channels might be but the overall trough isn`t.

    There again completely seperate trays held by the same struts etc could be just as onerous.

    Taking it further to another (silly) conclusion, a whole area/room/building is a "container".

    You need to not only read the particulare reg(s) but also it`s intention of how far we mitigate risks
Children
No Data