This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Following on from Competency and legacy NVQ3 thread

Hello friends,

Was there ever any update to the suggestion in the OP of this thread that things were being looked at?

Competent Person Scheme and legacy NVQ3 Qualifications - Wiring and the Regulations BS 7671 - IET EngX - IET EngX (theiet.org)

A year or so ago I found myself in the situation described in that thread.  I gave up my registration because I no longer needed it.  I'm still a full time Electrical Engineer, just not in construction or domestic. My hands are cleaner these days.  I decided to go back in order to look after my ageing parents' electrical installations and generally to keep my hand in. I miss being on the tools. I miss fault finding and I&T.  The local council won't take my I&Ts anymore, and so on.    It'll never be a decent income again but it's great to be able to help out.  I'm not the kind that gets A N Other in to do a certificate.   

Between being welcomed back and having a job ready for inspection, everything changed.  I should have been warned about that but it seemed to have slipped through the advice I was given.  I did get a full refund after a bit of a struggle.

The IET are blamed for the change by the way, in spades.  I can see from my research that's not  the case.

I decided to go for it.  Working on the basis that if my beloved industry is now telling me I'm not competent to re wire a bathroom or the like, then I need to get their confidence back.  I can shout and scream and cry about it all I want.  Believe me, I have done so.  Shouting and screaming didn't get me an agreement to re register though.   This whole process is not without its politics and when it is over, I have soo much to share with you. There is a diary of course.

So, here's the conundrum - 

Zs wants to re register.

An NVQ3 and an AM2E are suddenly required (£1800 NVQ3 which is entirely on line, with Zoom assessments, plus loads of costs) 

NVQ3 want to see my work and give me a list of what they'd like to see - Steel conduit, Distribution,Trunking, Smart, and so on.   

I can do that but I'm not supposed to be doing half the work the NVQ3 is asking to see..... No JIB card, no insurance without registration, cannot go out and help on a construction site- You get where I'm going with all this..

Rocks and Hard Places come to mind.

How are the jobs for the NVQ assessment being prepared unless by employees/ workers who do not have their badges yet?  

I promise you that this is not easy to do when you work full time already and don't go out to work on a construction site.  There is a clear focus on all this being in quest of a JIB card but it isn't  - I don't need a JIB card any more than I need some of the other things I'm asked to go for.  This is to get my registration back.  

I'm plodding through the NVQ3 now.  Yes, if you had time you could do it fairly quickly.  Then I will go to a college for the AM2E ( E for experience?  Old codgers assessment).. I am dreading that in such a big way.  

The plan is to book a place for that sometime about Easter - I'll see.  I'll have plenty of circuits to offer an NIC or NAPIT assessor by then.

Lyle, is your college a NET college?  I'd gladly come to yours.   I've noticed a touch of not being taken seriously with this process. understandable I suppose but I did think those days were gone.

Please let me know if there has been any change - before I go of to a college and get handed a bundle of SY cable to connect against the clock  (are they really asking for SY cable?).

Otherwise - hang in there. I did decide to do it and  I will be able to offer you perfect knowledge of it all before too long.

Zs 

Parents
  • Wow.  Thank you for those replies.

    The NVQ3, to me, is an expensive time and money inconvenience but I can do it. I'm  leaving every notifiable job on this journey a bit unfinished and I will complete and notify later.  I assume that is the portfolio you mention Tatty?  The AM2E, on the other hand fills me with dread reading your words.  Largely because of working to a time slot and of course because I never really was a boiler person. I did the Honeywell boiler wiring course course way back and since then always had time to scratch my head and research any boiler I was dealing with.

    Surely things have moved on from S plan and Y plan in recent 'smart' years?   Hey ho. 

    I didn't realise AM2E was so involved in terms of regs and guidance notes.  I should be OK with them because I  use them daily,  but will reinstate the books on the sofa.    Ooh, I must digress - I bought a copy of Birds Electrical Circuit Theory and Technology recently.  What an amazing book.  Nerd enhancing.  

    I shall be practising hard before AM2E comes along.  Lyle, I'm going to be asking you about whether or not you can run me through a mock AM2E when the time comes.  I reckon that would do me right and I love NI.

    What I'm seeing in this conversation is trauma.  I was planning to get it all bagged before posting but the support thing, you know.  People must be leaving in droves?  I know what you do and how well you do it Tatty - it must have been a backward step for you. Did you have to do this despite being registered with the NIC and not letting it go?  I sort of thought I was in this situation because I gave my registration up for a couple of years.   So is this affecting everyone with our type of qualification and industry experience?    Mine is almost identical to yours - 2360 2391 etc. and I have the 2396. 

    Chris, I want to see your birth certificate!  I don't believe you ;).  I'm too old to be doing this kind of thing myself but the wheels aren't falling off yet so I suppose I'm not thinking that far ahead.    I know the local BC are supposed to accept I&T from anyone,  but they've got it into their heads that registered is required and I've not got the mojo to fight it.   Nor would the insurers of a thatched cottage I have always looked after in terms of I&T. 

    What I do notice though is that our newcomers to the industry like to work with me, probably not scary, and I'm giving something back nowadays. They struggle to know which end of a screwdriver to hold but they have the required badges. so that's alright then. ...

    This isn't supported by the company I work for and I don't need it for them so I'm glad to read yours.  Sticking with it.  This might be turning into a personal pride issue.  Watch this space.

    thank you, Zs

     

Reply
  • Wow.  Thank you for those replies.

    The NVQ3, to me, is an expensive time and money inconvenience but I can do it. I'm  leaving every notifiable job on this journey a bit unfinished and I will complete and notify later.  I assume that is the portfolio you mention Tatty?  The AM2E, on the other hand fills me with dread reading your words.  Largely because of working to a time slot and of course because I never really was a boiler person. I did the Honeywell boiler wiring course course way back and since then always had time to scratch my head and research any boiler I was dealing with.

    Surely things have moved on from S plan and Y plan in recent 'smart' years?   Hey ho. 

    I didn't realise AM2E was so involved in terms of regs and guidance notes.  I should be OK with them because I  use them daily,  but will reinstate the books on the sofa.    Ooh, I must digress - I bought a copy of Birds Electrical Circuit Theory and Technology recently.  What an amazing book.  Nerd enhancing.  

    I shall be practising hard before AM2E comes along.  Lyle, I'm going to be asking you about whether or not you can run me through a mock AM2E when the time comes.  I reckon that would do me right and I love NI.

    What I'm seeing in this conversation is trauma.  I was planning to get it all bagged before posting but the support thing, you know.  People must be leaving in droves?  I know what you do and how well you do it Tatty - it must have been a backward step for you. Did you have to do this despite being registered with the NIC and not letting it go?  I sort of thought I was in this situation because I gave my registration up for a couple of years.   So is this affecting everyone with our type of qualification and industry experience?    Mine is almost identical to yours - 2360 2391 etc. and I have the 2396. 

    Chris, I want to see your birth certificate!  I don't believe you ;).  I'm too old to be doing this kind of thing myself but the wheels aren't falling off yet so I suppose I'm not thinking that far ahead.    I know the local BC are supposed to accept I&T from anyone,  but they've got it into their heads that registered is required and I've not got the mojo to fight it.   Nor would the insurers of a thatched cottage I have always looked after in terms of I&T. 

    What I do notice though is that our newcomers to the industry like to work with me, probably not scary, and I'm giving something back nowadays. They struggle to know which end of a screwdriver to hold but they have the required badges. so that's alright then. ...

    This isn't supported by the company I work for and I don't need it for them so I'm glad to read yours.  Sticking with it.  This might be turning into a personal pride issue.  Watch this space.

    thank you, Zs

     

Children
  • I'm in the same boat. I've paid my fee, but havent had time to do the portfolio yet, I've been doing an ASHP design course for the last month. To make you sick, I paid £1350 with 'The Guilds'.

    I've just spent 9 months on a large site, so, hopefully, there will be enough pics for me. Of the 15 or so sparkies on site, I was the only one without a Gold Card. Site Supervisor card got me on, and, I was the only one they trusted to fit out the plant rooms. Strange that, on paper, I was the least qualified one on site!

    As for new entrants with Gold Cards, well, I've met quite a few recently, and I wouldnt trust many of them. The last day on site was wiring up some outside bollard lights. A feed of 3 core SWA from one light to the next. Terminated in plastic Wiska boxes. I started to do a part finished one, and asked where the SWA banjos were. I was told they werent required, as the boxes are plastic. When I pointed out that it was to protect the outgoing cable, I was told to not bother as it was the last day on site. They all got a rocket up their backsides because of that. Not the type of people you'd want wiring anything without supervision, yet they had their Gold Cards!

  • What I'm seeing in this conversation is trauma.  I was planning to get it all bagged before posting but the support thing, you know.  People must be leaving in droves?  I know what you do and how well you do it Tatty - it must have been a backward step for you. Did you have to do this despite being registered with the NIC and not letting it go?  I sort of thought I was in this situation because I gave my registration up for a couple of years.   So is this affecting everyone with our type of qualification and industry experience?    Mine is almost identical to yours - 2360 2391 etc. and I have the 2396. 

    I've done this because - in September last year - the NICEIC effectively said (my interpretation here) that I'm not qualified without this........I can remain as a QS going forward but should I wish to change roles or let my membership lapse, then back into the unqualified bin I shall go. 

    I have the 2396 too - so tried to go straight for the JIB black card, but it seems you have to get the gold card first? 

    The NICEIC - in the industries I find my self running around in these last 10 years especially, seems to be becoming less and less valuable and the JIB more and more valuable. I've lost a couple of contracts because I'm not JIB and not a JIB company so I need to move towards JIB anyway.

    Also I see individual competency being unavoidable in the near future where we will all have to be able prove individual competencies........which is OK, tentatively; I fear, though, this will turn into licencing and we'll also all get pigeonholed into sectors of the electrical world that we are "licenced" to do. So if my card says I'm a domestic electrician for example, I'll be barred from doing commercial, or BMS, or simply install fire alarms or what ever the case might be. "Thin edge" and "wedge" come to mind.....Certainly in bigger commercial sites only the JIB gold card has ever held any relevance for the individual electricians working on the project. For myself, a black card would be more useful, so I'll probably try to sort that out next. (assuming I pass the AM2E and get approved for a gold card of course)

    Kind Regards

    Tatty