DNO Residential Supply Main Cutout Fuses and Potential Fault Current (PFC)

There seems to be a lot of emphasis on recording the highest value of PFC being less than the protective devises can safely handle, but little or no reference to when the pfc might be too low to operate the device in the prescribed time. In fact, most installation and inspection certificates simple note the device manufacturers maximum safe fault current, giving the electrician an excuse perhaps to not even measure the pfc!

I’m long retired but investigating a potentially serious electrical fire for a friend, though fortunately, this time, no fatalities as it was confined to a detached intake cabinet well away from the building. Which brings me to another point, the ESQC Regulations stress reporting an incident to the Secretary of State if any fatalities, but no such requirement if none (this time!). Sadly, a missed opportunity perhaps to reduce the risk of similar failures causing fatalities in future.

Anyway, for now, back to the pfc issue: In their case they had very recently had a 3 phase upgrade to their large property, with DNO 100amp cutout fuses (BS1361 or similar). The supply service cable serves several properties, with theirs being near the end of the supply service cable. Both the calculated pfc and measured value indicate around half the pfc required to operate the cutout fuses in the prescribed time, and in the event, persisted in the fault mode (apparently faulty meter or loose meter connection) for perhaps in excess of 15 minutes, further aiding the developing fire. Currently, their loads are all single phase and shared across the 3 phases, with ample capacity for future load additions.

So 2 questions if I may, one around the related ESQC regulations notification issue, and one about no obvious provision for recording a measured value of pfc on certificates, and no obvious requirement on the certificate to act accordingly when the measured pfc is too low.

Parents
  • Was this a TN supply please?

    If the PFC was too low, then presumably the Ze was too high.

    R.24 of the ESQCR 2002 makes the DNO and supplier responsible for ensuring that suitable fuses are fitted.

    24.—(1) A distributor or meter operator shall ensure that each item of his equipment which is on a consumer’s premises but which is not under the control of the consumer (whether forming part of the consumer’s installation or not) is—

    (a) suitable for its purpose;

    (b) installed and, so far as is reasonably practicable, maintained so as to prevent danger; and

    (c) protected by a suitable fusible cut-out or circuit breaker which is situated as close as is reasonably practicable to the supply terminals.

  • Thanks Chris, and yes, measured Ze around 0.45 ohms in this case, with measured pfc around 430 amps. Increasing load above around 45 amps, can cause the supply voltage to drop below the legal limit too, depending on other customers loads on the supply cable. We are currently involving the DNO and service provider, but so far, the DNO say their cutout fuses work fine, (fogging us off at this stage), and I'm about to challenge that, particularly since I first made them aware of the pfc issue back in 2019 when they were on a single phase supply. As part of converting to 3 phase, they first tried it as a PME system (TNC-S), then seem to have given up and connected as TNS, though at this stage, I'm not convinced that they removed an earth rod, installed when they moved to PME. Currently too, they seem to have a mix of SNE and PME customers fed off the same service cable, but I'm currently making further enquiries as I thought this was not allowed either. As for the fire, the new meter was mostly ash in the only photo that I've seen, and they took all the potentially forensic material away with them before I got involved. 

  • How do you go from TN-C-S to TN-S?

    I must say that my experience with the DNO (SSEN in England) was very good. I reported an elevated Ze at (IIRC) 0.85 Ω and they came round straightaway. They considered down-rating my main fuse, or even pulling it altogether, but just came back later on to change me to TN-C-S.

Reply
  • How do you go from TN-C-S to TN-S?

    I must say that my experience with the DNO (SSEN in England) was very good. I reported an elevated Ze at (IIRC) 0.85 Ω and they came round straightaway. They considered down-rating my main fuse, or even pulling it altogether, but just came back later on to change me to TN-C-S.

Children
No Data