Looking to understand a ramp test result

I visited a customer today who had an RCD tripping after a water spill on a hot plate.

It was a single RCD protecting the entire installation, Hager type AC, been trying to persuade her to change the board for a few years.


The bit that I find strange is that the RCD was seeing 15.9mA of earth leakage, measured with clamp meter across tails. RCD also tripped in 133mS with 30mA test from a socket.

I then did a ramp test on both 180 and 0 degrees, from a socket with the installation powered, expecting a very low trip current due to existing high leakage, but it tripped at 21mA on both directions. Either I missed something or there is something I don't understand about the RCD testing setup? The one thing I can see with hindsight is that I didn't repeat the tests with the MCB's switched off.

So why would the ramp have gone so high before tripping? This is on a TT earth with Zs @ DB of 17.5 ohms. Currently installations insulation resistance is only 0.47 M Ohms ar 250V, line / neutral joined to earth. I hope this improves as the hob dries out.

Parents
  • Mike Thanks for the input. phase angle had crossed my mind. I was thought for cable inductance had more of an influence than capacitance, just means phase lag rather than lead.

    It will be interesting to see what happens over the next few days, there isn't much in the way of electronics, but it's a fairly big home, actually two on a single RCD, one unoccupied. At some point the owner is going to have to give in and change the CU, otherwise one day the rcd will trip and I won't be easily available across the road to help out.



  • Between  two rambling houses I suppose you may have half a km of cable in total and that could be 50nF ==  50,000pF, and at 50Hz that's about 60 kohms. On its own that accounts for perhaps 5mA  of leakage, but of course there could be  things like the capacitace from windings to core of a door bell transformer that might add a spare nanofarad. and there probably is some electronics. Circa 10nF of capacitance per device seems to be common. 

    If you want some numbers to conjure with, typical 2.5mm twin and earth measures between 60 and 100 picofarads from L or N to E with the unused core floating  and rather less L to N with E floating.

    Inductance per unit length is a measure of the energy stored in magnetic fields around moving charges (currents) and for that typical cable again is about 1 micro Henry per metre if only one core is carrying current; but if the flow and return currents in the cable are balanced so current in  L = minus current in N the round loop inductance is quite a lot less than the sum of the inductances of the two cores, as the magnetic fields oppose and overlap and partly  cancel - you may see as little as a few tens of nano-henries for a line pair.

    Capacitance is only a measure of the energy stored in the electric fields around and between conductors at differing voltages - there does not have to be anything that actually  looks like capacitor plates - that is just a good  shape for getting maximum C in minimum volume. (As a none standard capacitor shape, a plump human on a step ladder has about 500 - 1000 pF to the rest of the planet, and may feel a small tingle from a live wire despite being insulated to DC.)

    As per above, all these effects in wire alone can normally be safely ignored at 50Hz unless you have very long lengths or are interested in effects that are a small fraction of  the  currents and voltages in a typical load.


    Capacitance in parallel is more significant when the thing you are trying to measure is a low current, and the effect of a series inductance is more significant when it is carrying a large current. 

    Generally in the earth path the currents are small, so the fraction of the 230V across the capacitance will dominate.

    Mike.

  • Between  two rambling houses I suppose you may have half a km of cable in total

    That seems a lot. 10 circuits at 50 m each?

Reply Children
No Data