This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

ARE CENG AND IENG EQUAL IN STATUS

Can we say that the CEng and IEng be considered equal titles in professional status or IEng is inferior than CEng.

As the Application Form for both CEng and IEng is same.
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Sparkingchip

    Wow,

    My computer '2004 HP
    portable, just crashed, by the time I got back on line I saw these
    emails.

    Don't you guys have homes
    and other interests?




    I did my bit, ITEME to IIE,
    every thing was going well, we were even changing ideas at ECUK,
    then IEE came along and look at the mess now, they have denigrated
    professional engineers at HNC or BSc level and the rest are keeping
    their heads down. Well they have careers, mine is over, it was
    tough and amusing, and with I Eng you can lead engineering
    worldwide.




    I'm retired, i have started
    the ball rolling, it's up to the next generation to sort out this
    bag of worms ang get it to fit BREXIT at the same
    time.




    These same CEn g and pompous
    High status plagiarised my name and patented my work, and then IET
    went crawiling after them to get onto the FUSION
    wagon.




    Well, I'm going to sort out
    my own problem, it is the biggest TECHNOLOGY corruption plot ever,
    if I get some recognition, the world will know of it;  
     ' there will be a Fusion bomb explosion 'metaphorically' now
    its not the blog manager thats going to coùplain its
    GCHQ.




    Do or die.




    Goog luck

    John Gowman










  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Sparkingchip

    Wow,

    My computer '2004 HP
    portable, just crashed, by the time I got back on line I saw these
    emails.

    Don't you guys have homes
    and other interests?




    I did my bit, ITEME to IIE,
    every thing was going well, we were even changing ideas at ECUK,
    then IEE came along and look at the mess now, they have denigrated
    professional engineers at HNC or BSc level and the rest are keeping
    their heads down. Well they have careers, mine is over, it was
    tough and amusing, and with I Eng you can lead engineering
    worldwide.




    I'm retired, i have started
    the ball rolling, it's up to the next generation to sort out this
    bag of worms ang get it to fit BREXIT at the same
    time.




    These same CEn g and pompous
    High status plagiarised my name and patented my work, and then IET
    went crawiling after them to get onto the FUSION
    wagon.




    Well, I'm going to sort out
    my own problem, it is the biggest TECHNOLOGY corruption plot ever,
    if I get some recognition, the world will know of it;  
     ' there will be a Fusion bomb explosion 'metaphorically' now
    its not the blog manager thats going to coùplain its
    GCHQ.




    Do or die.




    Goog luck

    John Gowman










  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Sparkingchip

    Wow,

    My computer '2004 HP
    portable, just crashed, by the time I got back on line I saw these
    emails.

    Don't you guys have homes
    and other interests?




    I did my bit, ITEME to IIE,
    every thing was going well, we were even changing ideas at ECUK,
    then IEE came along and look at the mess now, they have denigrated
    professional engineers at HNC or BSc level and the rest are keeping
    their heads down. Well they have careers, mine is over, it was
    tough and amusing, and with I Eng you can lead engineering
    worldwide.




    I'm retired, i have started
    the ball rolling, it's up to the next generation to sort out this
    bag of worms ang get it to fit BREXIT at the same
    time.




    These same CEn g and pompous
    High status plagiarised my name and patented my work, and then IET
    went crawiling after them to get onto the FUSION
    wagon.




    Well, I'm going to sort out
    my own problem, it is the biggest TECHNOLOGY corruption plot ever,
    if I get some recognition, the world will know of it;  
     ' there will be a Fusion bomb explosion 'metaphorically' now
    its not the blog manager thats going to coùplain its
    GCHQ.




    Do or die.




    Goog luck

    John Gowman










  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Sparkingchip

    Wow,

    My computer '2004 HP
    portable, just crashed, by the time I got back on line I saw these
    emails.

    Don't you guys have homes
    and other interests?




    I did my bit, ITEME to IIE,
    every thing was going well, we were even changing ideas at ECUK,
    then IEE came along and look at the mess now, they have denigrated
    professional engineers at HNC or BSc level and the rest are keeping
    their heads down. Well they have careers, mine is over, it was
    tough and amusing, and with I Eng you can lead engineering
    worldwide.




    I'm retired, i have started
    the ball rolling, it's up to the next generation to sort out this
    bag of worms ang get it to fit BREXIT at the same
    time.




    These same CEn g and pompous
    High status plagiarised my name and patented my work, and then IET
    went crawiling after them to get onto the FUSION
    wagon.




    Well, I'm going to sort out
    my own problem, it is the biggest TECHNOLOGY corruption plot ever,
    if I get some recognition, the world will know of it;  
     ' there will be a Fusion bomb explosion 'metaphorically' now
    its not the blog manager thats going to coùplain its
    GCHQ.




    Do or die.




    Goog luck

    John Gowman











  • John Gowman:



     
    To be a member of a PEI you have to be recommended by members as in the Free Masons or the Golf Club. This is a very old English tradition. You have to be reviewed by members to be accepted.


    This is the first objection to CEng registration. You have to please some very unpleasant persons.




    Or you just ask the person sitting at the desk next to you to countersign the application.


    Ever since MIET was separated from Chartered Electrical Engineer, the bar for membership has been pretty low.  If you have a degree in engineering or something technology-related, and work in engineering or technology, then you just need to find someone who will sign the form.


    Perhaps it's all a metter of where you work.  Where I am, you can't move for tripping over Chartered Engineers.  They are just the people I work with every day, and have no reason to try to keep me out of their club.

  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member
    I did a Fitter/Machinist(I suppose a new term for Fitter & Turner) appie-ship in Zimbabwe, was moved into the drawing office, got a CGLI Full Tech Cert.(and a SilverMedal). Became an Engineering Technician and then was upgraded to IEng after working my way up to an engineer. Ultimately my lack of a degree is what causes me not to be able to apply for jobs. Even if I do, I have no doubt the software filters me out. I hope the designation would indicate to a potential employer that I have attained a certain level of experience and ability. The reality is that formal education is what counts, especially in the day of computerised job applications.
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member
    Anthony when you earned your IEng did you apply for GCGI from City and Guilds?

    GCGI academical equal to BENg degree.

    In USA for example it was evaluated by NACES member agency as equivalent to Bachelors of Engineering degree from US University.

    Persons who earned GCGI put on the resume that its academic equivalent is BEng degree.  So no software filters can block it.

    But also with FTC (or FTD) and IEng you can apply to a  final year of some BEng programs and complete the degree in a year.


    The Full Tech Cert was regarded as broadly equivalent to the Higher National Certificate, though perhaps rather more specialied in scope. It was accepted as satisfying the academic requirements for the old T.Eng.



    M. M. Waserman BTEE, MCGI, CEng MBCS, MIET, CBT

  • Daniel, thanks for the link smiley I really must read that report properly sometime, Not while it's sunny though smiley
  • Re filtering out non-graduates: It's not just software though, there's the human filters as well sad The only solution I know is apply, apply, apply. And, as all advisors on recruitment would say, try to make contact with actual engineering managers rather than HR staff.


    And make as many personal contacts as you possibly can. The job market genuinely is a totally unfair "old boy's club" (it's called the free market wink) where huge numbers of jobs are "won" by chatting to the right person in the bar before the jobs are even advertised. From the recruiter's side there is a genuine advantage to this (apart from saving lots of cash and time), if you take someone on from a personal recommendation you can (if you trust the person making the recommendation) find out the whole back story for the person you're taking on. Whereas people can, and do, blag their way through CVs and interviews. So you want yourself to be somebody who's getting recommendations, then qualifications become far less of an issue. I'm sure people here will start shouting "that's unfair!" - tough, it's very often the way it works.


    We're off topic here really, but it's a very important issue - particularly for IEng level engineers who've come up the non-graduate root. I'd strongly recommend two very old but still worthwhile books. "Perfect CV" and "Perfect Interview" by Max Eggert. You may not like what he says, but he describes brilliantly how recruitment actually works and how to work with it.


    Final point (which I've said many times here over many many years), a good trick which has worked for me every time I've changed jobs is to apply for a job lower in level than the one you are doing now. In my case, either I was taken on for the job I applied for and then very rapidly promoted (I have never applied for a promotion in my career!) or - in the most recent case - they offered me a higher level job, which I wasn't on paper (but was in practice) qualified for, straight away. May not work for everybody but did for me.


    Right, I'm going out into the sun now smiley Apologies for any typos.


    Cheers, Andy
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member
    Moshe. I did not know about the IEng allowing me to get the 'upgrade' from CGLI. Is this still available? I have had a look at the top-up degree from the University of Portsmouth. My main concern is that my maths might be a bit rusty. Are there any other English universities offering an online 'top-up degree?