This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Circuit Breaker Selection

Hi

I have to decide on a circuit breaker for a 22 KW, 3 phase 400V Air compressor. 
Load current = P / (1.732 * V *PF) =22000 /(1.732*400*0.8)
= 39.69A

Therefore a 40A Type D CB is used.

These are my questions:
1. Do we have to include the PF if not given in the equipment datasheet for current calculation.
2. Is this the right way to find the size of MCB? i will also be including an overload relay. Is there anything else i need to lookout for?

Thank you in advance for your help.

  • For a  running current of 39.6 amps I feel that a 40 amp MCB is too small for two reasons. Firstly a margin of 1% between normal load current and MCB rating may prove unreliable. If the actual voltage at the motor falls to only 360 volts, (supply voltage 5% low and another 5% voltage drop in the wiring)

    And secondly consider starting current, this might trip a 40 amp MCB. A D type as is suggested is fairly resistant to starting currents, but still seems a bit small.

  • Hi thank you for replying. I understand what you explained. you mentioned about the voltage drop and how it wont be reliable to size a CB based on load current. Can you please suggest how else to calculate or guide me where i can find the material for the same.

    Thank you again.

  • For a potentially long hour load, I would consider it good practice to size a fuse or an MCB at at least 110% of the calculated or stated running current, rounded up to the next standard size. This allows for supply voltage variations and manufacturing tolerances. So for a 39.6 amp load use a 45 amp fuse or MCB as a minimum.

    Additional upsizing may be required for motors due to the starting current. This depends on the starting method used, and guidance may be obtained from the supplier of the equipment.

  • Thank you for clearing it for me. Just a doubt. The figure 110%, (5%+5%) you got in accordance with BS 7671 right?

  • I am not aware of any SPECIFIC regulatory requirement to allow a 10% margin but would presume that this comes under accepted good practice/good design.

    It depends a bit on the nature of the load and reasonably expected use. For a load expected to be used continually throughout the working day I would allow a 10%margin as described.  For a load used only briefly I might not bother.