Please I would like to know what percentage of cross section area should my neutral cable be with respect to the live conductor for a total harmonic distortion limit of less then 5% at nominal frequency of 50Hz
Please I would like to know what percentage of cross section area should my neutral cable be with respect to the live conductor for a total harmonic distortion limit of less then 5% at nominal frequency of 50Hz
Sounds like something for section 5.5 of appendix 4 of BS 7671. You probably need a few more details (like how well loads are balanced across phases) to get a complete answer, but as I read it an ordinary full size N (i.e. 100% of L) will cope with up to 15% distortion.
- Andy.
Without further information on the % of each harmonic, you could only assume that most of the distortion will be triple-n harmonics.
Table 4Aa of BS 7671:2018+A2:2022 indicates that the neutral can be sized simply for (line current x 1.0) with 3rd harmonic content of 5 %.
The above advise is current guidance for UK installations.
For triple-n harmonics exceeding 33 %, the factor is applied to a calculated neutral current, not the line current.
Example calculations are given in 5.5.2 in Appendix 4 to BS 7671:2018+A2:2022.
thank you for your response Sir, so from BS 7671 I can see it uses "assumptions" of wether the load MAY or MAY NOT produce harmonics. Does this mean I just have to "predict" (for lack of a better word) if a load would produce harmonic distortions?
The manufacturer should provide information on harmonic distortion of equipment one way or another, especially in the UK or the EU. This might be:
In the UK, and in a number of EU countries, there are limits for total combined harmonic distortion of installations - in the UK the installation designer must demonstrate conformity to ENA Engineering Recommendation G5 (current version I believe is G5/5)
I did wonder why this has not been moved to 'Wiring and the Regulations' as it's BS 7671-related ?
Interestingly, the design software I use automatically provides a Total Harmonic Distortion percentage based on the type of load, which can be quite helpful.
is your load 3-phase 3-wire, like most motor drives, or a collection of single phase connections? if the disturbing load isn't connected to the neutral, then it can't draw any current through the neutral
if the three phase 3-wire load has one of it`s lines broken, I think it would create an unbalanced load in the neutral even though ithe neutral isn`t connected to it
if the three phase 3-wire load has one of it`s lines broken, I think it would create an unbalanced load in the neutral even though ithe neutral isn`t connected to it
Think again - there can't be current in the N if there's no N conductor. Loads can either be connected directly between lines, in which case there's just current flowing in two lines if one is broken - potentially with two of the loads connected in series between the two remaining lines. If loads are connected in star without a N connection, then the voltage on the star point will move away from 0V until things equalize (similarly some loads connected in series across lines).
- Andy.
Think again - there can't be current in the N if there's no N conductor.
That's an interesting perspective, but I'm not sure that's always the case either .... if there are single-phase 400 V loads (or broken three-phase 400 V delta loads) connected alongside fully balanced single-phase 230 V loads, and 400 V TP&N loads, in a three-phase 4-wire system, harmonics can still travel in the 4-wire neutral upstream of a 3-wire circuit, and unbalance even in only delta-connected or line-line connected loads could cause neutral current based on volt-drop causing unbalance in the star-connected and single-phase loads.
We're about to take you to the IET registration website. Don't worry though, you'll be sent straight back to the community after completing the registration.
Continue to the IET registration site